London was greatly agitated. The Presbyterians
and the orthodox generally were eager for Biddle’s
conviction; but a very considerable number of persons,
including not only Biddle’s own followers and
free-thinkers of other sorts, but also some Independent
and Baptist ministers, whose orthodoxy was beyond
suspicion, bestirred themselves in his behalf.
Pamphlets appeared in that interest, one entitled
The Spirit of Persecution again broken loose against
Mr. John Biddle, and a numerously signed petition
was addressed to Cromwell, requesting his merciful
interference. The Petition, as we learn from
Mercurius Politicus, was very badly managed.
“The persons who presented a petition some few
days since to his Highness on the behalf of Biddle,”
says that paper under date Sept. 28, “came this
day in expectation of an answer. They had access,
and divers godly ministers were present. And,
the Petition being read in the hearing of divers of
those under whose countenance it was presented, many
of them disowned it, as being altered both in the matter
and title of it since they signed it, and so looked
upon it as a forged thing, wherein both his Highness
and they were greatly abused, and desired that the
original which they signed might be produced; which
Mr. Ives and some others of the contrivers and presenters
of it were not able to do, nor had they anything to
say in excuse of so foul a miscarriage. Whereupon
they were dismissed, his Highness having opened to
them the evil of such a practice [tampering with petitions
after they had been signed], as also how inconsistent
it was for them, who professed to be members
of the Churches of Christ and to worship him with
the worship due to God, to give any countenance to
one who reproached themselves and all the Christian
Churches in the world as being guilty of idolatry:
showing that, if it be true which Mr. Biddle holds,
to wit that our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ is but
a creature, then all those who worship him with the
worship due to God are idolaters. His Highness
showed moreover that the maintainers of this opinion
of Mr. Biddle’s are guilty of great blasphemy
against Christ, who is God equal with the Father; and
he referred it to them to consider whether any who
loved the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity could give
any countenance to such a person as he is.”
But, while the petitioners were thus dismissed with
a severe lecture, Cromwell had made up his mind to
save Mr. Biddle. On the 5th of October it was
resolved by the Council that he should be removed
to the Isle of Scilly and there shut up; and Cromwell’s
warrant to that effect was at once issued. In
no other way could the trial have been quashed, and
it was the kindest thing that could have been done
for Biddle in the circumstances. He lived comfortably
enough in his seclusion in the distant Island for the
next two years and a half, receiving an allowance
of a hundred crowns per annum from Cromwell,
and employing his leisure in the deep study of the
Apocalypse and the preparation of a treatise against
the Doctrine of the Fifth Monarchy.[1]