of the continuance of Tithes, and it is dubious whether
some in that half of the House which voted against
Tithes would not have been for preserving a Church
Establishment or Preaching Ministry by some other
form of state-maintenance. Nor can one imagine,
even in those eager and revolutionary times, an utter
disregard of that principle of compensation for life-interests
which any Parliament now, contemplating a scheme of
Disestablishment, would consider binding in common
equity. The old Bishops, and the Prelatic Clergy,
indeed, had been disestablished without much consideration
of life-interests; but the procedure in their case
had been of a penal character, and it is unlikely
that it would have been equally unceremonious with
the new clergy of Presbyterians and Independents,
allowed generally to be orthodox. From any hesitation
on that score Milton is absolutely free. He sees
no difficulties, takes regard of none. It is
not with a flesh-and-blood world that he deals, a world
of men, and their wives, and their families, and their
yearly incomes, and their fixed residences and household
belongings. It is with a world of wax, or of
flesh and blood that must be content to be treated
as wax. It is thought right to disestablish the
Church: well, then, let the Clergy go! Abolish
tithes; provide no substitute; proclaim that, after
this day week, or the first day of the next year,
not a penny shall be paid to any man by the State for
preaching the Gospel, or doing any other act of the
ministry: and what then? Why, there will
be a flutter of consternation, of course, through
some ten thousand or twelve thousand parsonages; ten
thousand or twelve thousand clerical gentlemen will
stare bewilderedly for a while at their wives’
faces: but do not be too much concerned!
They will all shift very well for themselves when
they know they must; the best of them will find congregations
where they are, or in other places, and will work
all the harder; and, if the drones and dotards go
threadbare and starve for the rest of their lives,
that is but God’s way with such since the beginning
of the world! Be instant, be rapid, be decisive,
be thoroughgoing, O ye statesmen! What are vested
interests in the Church of Christ?
As the Restored Rumpers had already decreed that an
Established Church should be kept up in England, and
had gone no farther on the Tithes question than to
say that Tithes must be paid, as by use and wont,
until some substitute should be provided, it is not
likely that, however long they had sat, Milton’s
views would have had much countenance from them.
There were individuals among them of Milton’s
way of thinking on the whole; but he had probably made
a mistake in fancying that he had materially improved
his influence, or the chances of his notions of Church-polity,
by his public re-adhesion to the Rump. In fact,
the continued existence of the Rump was more precarious
than he had thought. In August 1659, while his
pamphlet was in circulation, Lambert was away in the