authorities, Irenaeus and Origen, cited for like distinction
between spirit and soul in such a manner as to show
that the former must necessarily be regarded as separable
from the latter. In the distinction itself there
is of course no novelty for the most moderately well-informed.
It is insisted upon in many modern works, among which
may be mentioned Heard’s “Trichotomy of
Man” and Green’s “Spiritual Philosophy”;
the latter being an exposition of Coleridge’s
opinion on this and cognate subjects. But the
difficulty of regarding the two principles as separable
in fact as well as in logic arises from the senses,
if it is not the illusion of personal identity.
That we are particle, and that one part only is immortal,
the non-metaphysical mind rejects with the indignation
which is always encountered by a proposition that
is at once distasteful and unintelligible. Yet
perhaps it is not a greater difficulty (if, indeed,
it is not the very same) than that hard saying which
troubled Nicodemus, and which has been the key-note
of the mystical religious consciousness ever since.
This, however, is too extensive and deep a question
to be treated in this paper, which has for its object
chiefly to call attention to the distinctions introduced
by ancient thought into the conception of body as
the instrument or “vehicle” of soul.
That there is a correspondence between the spiritual
condition of man and the medium of his objective activity
every spiritualist will admit to be probable, and
it may well be that some light is thrown on future
states by the possibility or the manner of spirit
communication with this one.
—C. C. Massey
The Nilgiri Sannyasis
I was told that Sannyasis were sometimes met with
on a mountain called Velly Mallai Hills, in the Coimbatore
District, and trying to meet with one, I determined
to ascend this mountain. I traveled up its steep
sides and arrived at an opening, narrow and low, into
which I crept on all fours. Going up some twenty
yards I reached a cave, into the opening of which
I thrust my head and shoulders. I could see into
it clearly, but felt a cold wind on my face, as if
there was some opening or crevice—so I
looked carefully, but could see nothing. The
room was about twelve feet square. I did not
go into it. I saw arranged round its sides stones
one cubit long, all placed upright. I was much
disappointed at there being no Sannyasi, and came back
as I went, pushing myself backwards as there was no
room to turn. I was then told Sannyasis had
been met with in the dense sholas (thickets), and as
my work lay often in such places, I determined to
prosecute my search, and did so diligently, without,
however, any success.