passing through the Crystal Palace. For this service
you are to be paid; but to enable you to receive payment
you need the aid of the legislator, as the common
law grants no more copyright for the form in which
ideas are expressed than for the ideas themselves.
In granting this aid he is required to see that, while
he secures that you have justice, he does no injustice
to the men who produce the raw material of your books,
nor to the community whose common property it is.
In granting it, he is bound to use his efforts to
attain the knowledge needed for enabling him to do
justice to all parties, and not to you alone.
The laws which elsewhere govern the distribution of
the proceeds of labor, must apply in your case with
equal force. Looking at them, we see that, with
the growth of population and of wealth, there is everywhere
a tendency to diminution in the proportion of the
product that is allowed to the men who stand between
the producer and the consumer. In new settlements,
trade is small and the shopkeeper requires large profits
to enable him to live; and, while the consumer pays
a high price, the producer is compelled to be content
with a low one. In new settlements, the miller
takes a large toll for the conversion of corn into
flour, and the spinner and weaver take a large portion
of the wool as their reward for converting the balance
into cloth. Nevertheless, the shopkeeper, the
miller, the spinner, and the weaver are poor, because
trade is small. As wealth and population grow,
we find the shopkeeper gradually reducing his charge,
until from fifty it falls to five per cent.; the miller
reducing his, until he finds that he can afford to
give all the flour that is yielded by the corn, retaining
for himself the bran alone; and the spinner and weaver
contenting himself with a constantly diminishing proportion
of the wool; and now it is that we find shopkeepers,
millers, and manufacturers grow rich, while consumers
are cheaply supplied because of the vast increase
of trade. In your case, however, the course of
proceeding has been altogether different. Half
a century since, when our people were but four millions
in number, and were poor and scattered, gentlemen
like you were secured in the monopoly of their works
for fourteen years, with a power of renewal for a similar
term. Twenty years since, when the population
had almost tripled, and their wealth had sixfold increased,
and when the facilities of distribution had vastly
grown, the term was fixed at twenty-eight years, with
renewal to widow or children for fourteen years more.
At the present moment, you are secured in a monopoly
for forty-two years, among a population of twenty-six
millions of people, certain, at the close of twenty
years more, to be fifty millions and likely, at the
close of another half century, to be a hundred millions,
and with facilities, for the disposal of your products,
growing at a rate unequaled in the world. With
this vast increase of market, and increase of power