show how widely he casts his net:
Mysteries
of Udolpho, Romance of the Forest, Children of the
Abbey, Sir Charles Grandison, Pamela, Clarissa Harlowe,
Evelina, Camilla, Cecilia, La Nouvelle Heloise, Rasselas,
The Delicate Distress, Caroline of Lichfield,[98]
The Knights of the Swan,[99]
The Beggar
Girl, The Romance of the Highlands.[100] Besides
these novels, which he actually names, Barrett alludes
indirectly to several others, among them
Tristram
Shandy and
Amelia. From this enumeration
it is evident that Barrett was satirising the heroine,
not merely of the “novel of terror,” but
of the “sentimental novel” from which
she traced her descent. He organises a masquerade,
mindful that it is always the scene of the heroine’s
“best adventure,” with Fielding’s
Amelia and Miss Burney’s
Cecilia
and probably other novels in view. The precipitate
flight of Cherubina, “dressed in a long-skirted
red coat stiff with tarnished lace, a satin petticoat,
satin shoes and no stockings,” and with hair
streaming like a meteor, described in Letter XX, is
clearly a cruel mockery of Cecilia’s distressful
plight in Miss Burney’s novel. Even Scott
is not immune from Barrett’s barbed arrows, and
Byron is glanced at in the bogus antique language of
“Eftsoones.” Barrett, indeed, jeers
at the mediaeval revival in its various manifestations
and even at “Romanticism” generally, not
merely at the new school of fiction represented by
Mrs. Radcliffe, her followers and rivals. Not
content with reaching his aim, as he does again and
again in
The Heroine, Barrett, like many another
parodist, sometimes over-reaches it, and sneers at
what is not in itself ridiculous.
Nominally Cherubina is the butt of Barrett’s
satire, but the permanent interest of the book lies
in the skilful stage-managing of her lively adventures.
There is hardly an attempt at characterisation.
The people are mere masqueraders, who amuse us by
their costume and mannerisms, but reveal no individuality.
The plot is a wild extravaganza, crammed with high-flown,
mock-romantic episodes. Cherry Wilkinson, as the
result of a surfeit of romances, perhaps including
The Misanthropic Parent or The Guarded Secret
(1807), by Miss Smith, deserts her real father—a
worthy farmer—to look for more aristocratic
parents. As he is not picturesque enough for
a villain, she repudiates him with scorn: “Have
you the gaunt ferocity of famine in your countenance?
Can you darken the midnight with a scowl? Have
you the quivering lip and the Schedoniac contour?
In a word, are you a picturesque villain full of plot
and horror and magnificent wickedness? Ah! no,
sir, you are only a sleek, good-humoured, chuckle-headed,
old gentleman.” In the course of her search
she meets with amazing adventures, which she describes
in a series of letters to her governess. She
changes her name to Cherubina de Willoughby, and journeys
to London, where, mistaking Covent Garden Theatre