After they were gone grandmother said, “Emma, if I’s you, I’d put a stop to that chap’s flirtin’ so with Car’line Howard.”

Emma laughed gaily as she replied, “Oh, grandma, I can trust Harley; I have been sick so long that he has the privilege of walking or riding with anybody he pleases.”

Grandmother shook her head, saying, “It wasn’t so with her and our poor grandfather;” then I fell into a fit of musing as to whether grandma was ever young, and if she ever fixed her hair before the glass, as Anna did when she expected the doctor!  In the midst of my reverie Mr. Ashmore returned, and for the remainder of the evening devoted himself so entirely to Emma that I forgave him for going home with Carrie.  Next day, however, he found the walk to Captain Howard’s a very convenient one, staying a long time, too.  The next day it was the same, and the next, and the next, until I fancied that even Emma began to be anxious.

Grandma was highly indignant, and Sally declared, “that, as true as she lived and breathed, if Mike should serve her so, he’d catch it.”  About this time Agnes went home.  The evening before she left she spent at our house with Emma, of whom she seemed to be very fond.  Carrie and Ashmore were, as usual, out riding or walking, and the conversation naturally turned upon them.  At last, Anna, whose curiosity was still on the alert to know something of Penoyer, asked Agnes of him.  I will repeat, in substance, what Agnes said.

It seems that for many years Penoyer had been a teacher of music in Albany.  Agnes was one of his pupils, and while teaching her music he thought proper to fall overwhelmingly in love with her.  This for a time she did not notice; but when his attentions became so pointed as to become a subject of remark, she very coolly tried to make him understand his position.  He persevered, however, until he became exceedingly impudent and annoying.

About this time there came well-authenticated stories of his being not only a professed gambler, but also very dissipated in his habits.  To this last charge Agnes could testify, as his breath had frequently betrayed him.  He was accordingly dismissed.  Still he perseveringly pursued her, always managing, if possible, to get near her in all public places, and troubling her in various ways.

At last Agnes heard that he was showing among her acquaintances two notes bearing her signature.  The contents of these notes he covered with his hand, exposing to view only her name.  She had twice written, requesting him to purchase some new piece of music, and it was these messages which he was now showing, insinuating that Agnes thought favorably of him, but was opposed by her father.  The consequence of this was, that the next time Agnes’ brother met Penoyer in the street, he gave him a sound caning, ordering him, under pain of a worse flogging, never again to mention his sister’s name.  This he was probably more willing to do, as he had already conceived a great liking for Carrie, who was silly enough to be pleased with and suffer his attentions.