talented writers, and he also knew how to draw from them and squeeze out of them all the literature they contained.  Tremendously headstrong, he has been known to keep a contributor under lock and key until his article was finished.  Authors abused him, quarrelled with him, and then came back to him again.  A review which had, for its first numbers, George Sand, Vigny, Musset, Merimee, among many others, as contributors, may be said to have started well.  George Sand tells us that after a battle with the Revue de Paris and the Revue des Deux Mondes, both of which papers wanted her work, she bound herself to the Revue des Deux Mondes, which was to pay her a hundred and sixty pounds a year for thirty-two pages of writing every six weeks.  In 1833 the Revue des Deux Mondes published Lelia, and on January 1, 1876, it finished publishing the Tour de Percemont.  This means an uninterrupted collaboration, extending over a period of forty-three years.

The literary critic of the Revue des Deux Mondes at that time was a man who was very much respected and very little liked, or, in other words, he was universally detested.  This critic was Gustave Planche.  He took his own role too seriously, and endeavoured to put authors on their guard about their faults.  Authors did not appreciate this.  He endeavoured, too, to put the public on guard against its own infatuations.  The public did not care for this.  He sowed strife and reaped revenge.  This did not stop him, though, for he went calmly on continuing his executions.  His impassibility was only feigned, and this is the curious side of the story.  He suffered keenly from the storms of hostility which he provoked.  He had a kindly disposition at bottom and tender places in his heart.  He was rather given to melancholy and intensely pessimistic.  To relieve his sadness, he gave himself up to hard work, and he was thoroughly devoted to art.  In order to comprehend this portrait and to see its resemblance, we, who knew our great Brunetiere, have only to think of him.  He, too, was noble, fervent and combative, and he sought in his exclusive devotion to literature a diversion from his gloomy pessimism, underneath which was concealed such kindliness.  It seemed with him, too, as though he took a pride in making a whole crowd of enemies, whilst in reality the discovery of every fresh adversary caused him great suffering.

When Lelia appeared, the novel was very badly treated in L’Europe litteraire.  Planche challenged the writer of the article, a certain Capo de Feuillide, to a duel.  So much for the impassibility of severe critics.  The duel took place, and afterwards there was a misunderstanding between George Sand and Planche.  From that time forth critics have given up fighting duels for the sake of authors.