both in the pulpit and in the confessional, and in
other and private discussions—I waited until
all should come here, and the conference should be
called as I desired, in order that everything might
be better reasoned out. Seeing now the great
delay of some, and that we would have to leave this
town—some alone, and others in company—have
taken the opinion of all the fathers who were to be
found here. They unanimously affirm that none
among all these islands have come into the power of
the Spaniards with just title. For, although
there are many and just causes for making war on some
nations or towns, no governor or captain can do so
without an express mandate for it from his Majesty,
excepting only that war which is waged in defense
of their persons and property, others being unjustly
undertaken; since neither in the first instructions
that we received, nor in later ones, has his Majesty
ordered us to make war on the natives of these islands.
Rather did he order the contrary, in a letter that
Juan de la Isla brought from his Majesty, written
from the Escorial to the governor (who is now in glory),
and which I saw. That letter declared that any
conquest made in these islands by force of arms, would
be unjust, even if there were cause for doing so.
All the more unjust are these conquests that in none,
or almost none, of them has there been any cause.
For as your Lordship knows, we have gone everywhere
with the mailed hand; and we have required the people
to be friends, and then to give us tribute. At
times war has been declared against them, because
they did not give as much as was demanded. And
if they would not give tribute, but defended themselves,
then they have been attacked, and war has been carried
on with fire and sword; and even on some occasions,
after the people have been killed and destroyed, and
their village taken, the Spaniards have sent men to
summon them to make peace. And when the Indians,
in order not to be destroyed, came to say that they
would like to be friends, the Spaniards have immediately
asked them for tribute, as they have done but recently
in all the villages of Los Camarines. [91] And wherever
the Indians, through fear of the Spaniards, have left
their houses and fled to the mountains, our people
have burned the houses or inflicted other great injuries.
I omit mention of the villages that are robbed without
awaiting peace, or those assaulted in the night-time.
Pretexts have been seized to subjugate all these villages,
and levy tribute on them, to such amount as can be
secured. With what conscience has a future tribute
been asked from them, before they knew us, or before
they have received any benefit from us? With what
right have three extortions, of large amounts of gold,
been made on the Ylocos, without holding any other
communication or intercourse with them, beyond going
there, and demanding gold of them, and then returning?
And I say the same of Los Camarines and of Acuyo,
and the other villages that are somewhat separated