may illustrate this point. Thus, he speaks of
two young girls of about 16 and 17, slightly neuropathic,
but without definite hysterical symptoms, who, during
the menstrual period, feel themselves in a sort of
electrical state, “with tingling and prickling
sensations and feelings of attraction or repulsion
at the contact of various objects.” These
girls believe their garments stick to their skin during
the periods; it was only with difficulty that they
could remove their slippers, though fitting easily;
stockings had to be drawn off violently by another
person, and they had given up changing their chemises
during the period because the linen became so glued
to the skin. An orchestral performer on the double-bass
informed Laurent that whenever he left a tuned double-bass
in his lodgings during his wife’s period a string
snapped; consequently he always removed his instrument
at this time to a friend’s house. He added
that the same thing happened two years earlier with
a mistress, a cafe-concert singer, who had,
indeed, warned him beforehand. A harpist also
informed Laurent that she had been obliged to give
up her profession because during her periods several
strings of her harp, always the same strings, broke,
especially when she was playing. A friend of
Laurent’s, an official in Cochin China, also
told him that the strings of his violin often snapped
during the menstrual periods of his Annamite mistress,
who informed him that Annamite women are familiar with
the phenomenon, and are careful not to play on their
instruments at this time. Two young ladies, both
good violinists, also affirmed that ever since their
first menstruation they had noted a tendency for the
strings to snap at this period; one, a genuine artist,
who often performed at charity concerts, systematically
refused to play at these times, and was often embarrassed
to find a pretext; the other, who admitted that she
was nervous and irritable at such times, had given
up playing on account of the trouble of changing the
strings so frequently. Laurent also refers to
the frequency with which women break things during
the menstrual periods, and considers that this is
not simply due to the awkwardness caused by nervous
exhaustion or hysterical tremors, but that there is
spontaneous breakage. Most usually it happens
that a glass breaks when it is being dried with a
cloth; needles also break with unusual facility at
this time; clocks are stopped by merely placing the
hand upon them.
I do not here attempt to estimate critically the validity of these alleged manifestations (some of which may certainly be explained by the unconscious muscular action which forms the basis of the phenomena of table-turning and thought-reading); such a task may best be undertaken through the minute study of isolated cases, and in this place I am merely concerned with the general influence of the menstrual state in affecting the social position of women, without reference to the analysis of the elements that go to make up that influence.