mass of people who form the lowest stratum of society.
The attitude of authority is bound to be repressive,
and great concentration of the governing power is needed
to neutralize the force of a popular movement.
This is the application of the principle that I unfolded
when I spoke just now of the way in which the class
privileged to govern should be restricted. If
this class is composed of men of ability, they will
obey this natural law, and compel the country to obey.
If you collect a crowd of mediocrities together, sooner
or later they will fall under the dominion of a stronger
head. A deputy of talent understands the reasons
for which a government exists; the mediocre deputy
simply comes to terms with force. An assembly
either obeys an idea, like the Convention in the time
of the Terror; a powerful personality, like the Corps
Legislatif under the rule of Napoleon; or falls under
the domination of a system or of wealth, as it has
done in our own day. The Republican Assembly,
that dream of some innocent souls, is an impossibility.
Those who would fain bring it to pass are either grossly
deluded dupes or would-be tyrants. Do you not
think that there is something ludicrous about an Assembly
which gravely sits in debate upon the perils of a
nation which ought to be roused into immediate action?
It is only right of course that the people should
elect a body of representatives who will decide questions
of supplies and of taxation; this institution has
always existed, under the sway of the most tyrannous
ruler no less than under the sceptre of the mildest
of princes. Money is not to be taken by force;
there are natural limits to taxation, and if they are
overstepped, a nation either rises up in revolt, or
lays itself down to die. Again, if this elective
body, changing from time to time according to the
needs and ideas of those whom it represents, should
refuse obedience to a bad law in the name of the people,
well and good. But to imagine that five hundred
men, drawn from every corner of the kingdom, will
make a good law! Is it not a dreary joke, for
which the people will sooner or later have to pay?
They have a change of masters, that is all.
“Authority ought to be given to one man, he
alone should have the task of making the laws; and
he should be a man who, by force of circumstances,
is continually obliged to submit his actions to general
approbation. But the only restraints that can
be brought to bear upon the exercise of power, be
it the power of the one, of the many, or of the multitude,
are to be found in the religious institutions of a
country. Religion forms the only adequate safeguard
against the abuse of supreme power. When a nation
ceases to believe in religion, it becomes ungovernable
in consequence, and its prince perforce becomes a
tyrant. The Chambers that occupy an intermediate
place between rulers and their subjects are powerless
to prevent these results, and can only mitigate them
to a very slight extent; Assemblies, as I have said