the Government ordered its officials to “pacify, imprison, put in irons, and thereby unteach and frighten from the Tartar faith those who, though baptised, do not obey the admonitions of the Metropolitan.”  These energetic measures proved as ineffectual as the spiritual exhortations; and Catherine II. adopted a new method, highly characteristic of her system of administration.  The new converts—­who, be it remembered, were unable to read and write—­were ordered by Imperial ukaz to sign a written promise to the effect that “they would completely forsake their infidel errors, and, avoiding all intercourse with unbelievers, would hold firmly and unwaveringly the Christian faith and its dogmas"*—­of which latter, we may add, they had not the slightest knowledge.  The childlike faith in the magical efficacy of stamped paper here displayed was not justified.  The so-called “baptised Tartars” are at the present time as far from being Christians as they were in the sixteenth century.  They cannot openly profess Mahometanism, because men who have been once formally admitted into the National Church cannot leave it without exposing themselves to the severe pains and penalties of the criminal code, but they strongly object to be Christianised.

     * “Ukaz Kazanskoi dukhovnoi Konsistorii.”  Anno 1778.

On this subject I have found a remarkable admission in a semiofficial article, published as recently as 1872.* “It is a fact worthy of attention,” says the writer, “that a long series of evident apostasies coincides with the beginning of measures to confirm the converts in the Christian faith.  There must be, therefore, some collateral cause producing those cases of apostasy precisely at the moment when the contrary might be expected.”  There is a delightful naivete in this way of stating the fact.  The mysterious cause vaguely indicated is not difficult to find.  So long as the Government demanded merely that the supposed converts should be inscribed as Christians in the official registers, there was no official apostasy; but as soon as active measures began to be taken “to confirm the converts,” a spirit of hostility and fanaticism appeared among the Mussulman population, and made those who were inscribed as Christians resist the propaganda.

     * “Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnago Prosveshtcheniya.”  June,
     1872.

It may safely be said that Christians are impervious to Islam, and genuine Mussulmans impervious to Christianity; but between the two there are certain tribes, or fractions of tribes, which present a promising field for missionary enterprise.  In this field the Tartars show much more zeal than the Russians, and possess certain advantages over their rivals.  The tribes of Northeastern Russia learn Tartar much more easily than Russian, and their geographical position and modes of life bring them in contact with Russians much less than with Tartars.  The consequence is that whole villages of Tcheremiss and Votiaks, officially inscribed as