it is their nature and so forth. They even suggest
that a cat is no more cruel in eating robin than we
are cruel ourselves in eating chicken. This seems
to me to be quibbling. In the first place, there
is an immense difference between a robin and a chicken.
In the second place, we are willing to share our chicken
with the cat—at least, we are willing to
share the skin and such of the bones as are not required
for soup. Besides, a cat has not the same need
of delicacies as a human being. It can eat, and
even digest, anything. It can eat the black skin
of filleted plaice. It can eat the bits of gristle
that people leave on the side of their plates.
It can eat boiled cod. It can eat New Zealand
mutton. There is no reason why an animal with
so undiscriminating a palate should demand song-birds
for its food, when even human beings, who are fairly
unscrupulous eaters, have agreed in some measure to
abstain from them. On reflection, however, I
doubt if it is his appetite for birds that makes the
cat with the yellow eyes feel guilty. If you were
able to talk to him in his own language, and formulate
your accusations against him as a bird-eater, he would
probably be merely puzzled and look on you as a crank.
If you pursued the argument and compelled him to moralise
his position, he would, I fancy, explain that the
birds were very wicked creatures and that their cruelties
to the worms and the insects were more than flesh
and blood could stand. He would work himself
up into a generous idealisation of himself as the
guardian of law and order amid the bloody strife of
the cabbage-patch—the preserver of the
balance of nature. If cats were as clever as
we, they would compile an atrocities blue-book about
worms. Alas, poor thrush, with how bedraggled
a reputation you would come through such an exposure!
With how Hunnish a tread you would be depicted treading
the lawn, sparing neither age nor sex, seizing the
infant worm as it puts out its head to take its first
bewildered peep at the rolling sun! Cats could
write sonnets on such a theme.... Then there
is that other beautiful potential poem, The Cry
of the Snail.... How tender-hearted cats
are! Their sympathy seems to be all but universal,
always on the look out for an object, ready to extend
itself anywhere where it is needed, except, as is but
human, to their victims. Yellow eyes or not,
I begin to be persuaded that the cat next door is
a noble fellow. It may well be that his look as
I pass is a look not of fear but of repulsion.
He has seen me going out among the worms with a sharp—no,
not a very sharp—spade, and regards me as
no better than an ogre. If I could only explain
to him! But I shall never be able to do so.
He could no more appreciate my point of view about
worms than I can appreciate his about robins.
Luckily, we both eat chicken. This may ultimately
help us to understand one another.