We finished the meal in silence.  It was not a long one, for I, at least, was anxious to get back to Swain.  As we rejoined him on the porch, Dr. Hinman’s car came up the drive.  He got out and shook hands with us.  As he greeted Swain, I saw him glance anxiously into his eyes—­and saw also that the glance reassured him.

“You’re feeling better to-day,” he said, sitting down by Swain’s side.

“Yes,” said Swain quietly, “I’m feeling all right again.”

“How is Miss Vaughan, doctor?” I asked.

Swain jerked round toward the doctor.

“Is Miss Vaughan ill?” he demanded.

“She had a shock last night,” answered the doctor, slowly; “but she’s getting along nicely.  She’ll have to be kept quiet for a few days.”

I was looking at Swain curiously.  He was rubbing his head perplexedly, as though trying to bring some confused memory to the surface of his mind.

“I seem to remember,” he said, “that Miss Vaughan fainted, and that I picked her up.”  Then he stopped and stared at us.  “Is her father dead?”

“Yes,” I said, and he fell to rubbing his head again.

I glanced at Hinman, and he nodded slightly.  I took it for assurance that Swain might be questioned.  Godfrey, who had gone indoors to get some cigars, came back with a handful.  All of us, including Swain, lighted up.

“Now, Swain,” I began, “I want you to tell us all that you remember of last night’s happenings.  Both Mr. Godfrey and Dr. Hinman are in my confidence and you may speak freely before them.  I want them to hear your story, because I want their advice.”

There was a pucker of perplexity on Swain’s face.

“I’ve been trying, ever since I woke up this morning, to straighten out my remembrance of last night,” he began, slowly; “but I haven’t succeeded very well.  At least, everything seems to stop right in the middle.”

“Go ahead,” I said, “and tell us what you do remember.  Maybe it will grow clearer as you recall it, or maybe we can fill in the gaps.  Begin at the moment you went over the wall.  We know everything that happened up to that time.  You remember that clearly, don’t you?”

“Oh, yes,” said Swain.  “I remember all that,” and he settled back in his chair.  “Well, after I went down the ladder, I found myself in a clump of shrubbery, and beyond that was a path.  I knew that the arbour where I was to meet Miss Vaughan was in the corner of the grounds at the back next to Mr. Godfrey’s place, so I turned back along the wall, leaving the path, which curved away from it.  It was very dark under the trees, and I had to go slowly for fear of running into one of them.  But I finally found the arbour.  I struck a match to assure myself that it was empty, and then sat down to wait.  Once or twice I fancied I heard some one moving outside, but it was only the wind among the trees, I guess, for it was fully half an hour before Miss Vaughan came.”