a local and immediate fulfilment in the circumstances
of the time. Matthew ii. 15 is only made into
a prophecy by taking the second half of a historical
reference in Hosea to the Exodus of Israel from Egypt;
it would be as reasonable to prove in this fashion
that the Bible teaches a denial of God, “as
is spoken by David the prophet, There is no God.”
The fulfilment of the saying of Jeremy the prophet
is as true as all the preceding (verses 17, 18); Jeremy
bids Rahel not to weep for the children who are carried
into bondage, “for they shall come again from
the land of the enemy ... thy children shall come again
to their own border” (Jer. xxxi. 16, 17).
Very applicable to the slaughtered babes, and so honest
of “Matthew” to quote just so much of the
“prophecy” as served his purpose, leaving
out that which altered its whole meaning. After
these specimens, we are not surprised to find that—unable
to find a prophecy fit to twist to suit his object—our
evangelist quietly invents one, and (verse 23) uses
a prophecy which has no existence in what was “spoken
by the prophets.” It is needless to go through
all the other passages known as Messianic prophecies,
for they may all be dealt with as above; the guiding
rule is to refer to the Old Testament in each case,
and not to trust to the quotation as given in the New,
and then to read the whole context of the “prophecy,”
instead of resting content with the few words which,
violently wrested from their natural meaning, are
forced into a superficial resemblance with the story
recorded in the Gospels.
The second theory, which regards Jesus as a new hero
of the ancient sun-worship, is full of intensest interest.
Dupuis, in his great work on sun-worship ("Origines
de Tous les Cultes”) has drawn out in detail
the various sun-myths, and has pointed to their common
features. Briefly stated, these points are as
follows: the hero is born about Dec. 25th, without
sexual intercourse, for the sun, entering the winter
solstice, emerges in the sign of Virgo, the heavenly
virgin. His mother remains ever-virgin, since
the rays of the sun, passing through the zodiacal
sign, leave it intact. His infancy is begirt with
dangers, because the new-born sun is feeble in the
midst of the winter’s fogs and mists, which
threaten to devour him; his life is one of toil and
peril, culminating at the spring equinox in a final
struggle with the powers of darkness. At that
period the day and the night are equal, and both fight
for the mastery; though the night veil the sun, and
he seems dead; though he has descended out of sight,
below the earth, yet he rises again triumphant, and
he rises in the sign of the Lamb, and is thus the
Lamb of God, carrying away the darkness and death of
the winter months. Henceforth, he triumphs, growing
ever stronger and more brilliant. He ascends
into the zenith, and there he glows, “on the
right hand of God,” himself God, the very substance
of the Father, the brightness of his glory, and the