[47] This vessel, after trying to find—­or at least making such a claim—­the fleet in Mindanao and other islands, returned to New Spain, anchoring at Puerto de la Navidad August 9, 1565.  A relation by its captain Alonso de Arellano, gives an account of this voyage (published in Col. doc. ined.  Ultramar, iii, no. 37, pp. 1-76).  Testimony as to the truth of this relation is given under oath by its author, his pilot Lope Martin, and others.  It is quite evident throughout that it was written with the hope of explaining satisfactorily the “San Lucas’s " sudden disappearance and failure to rejoin the flagship.  Accounts of islands passed by the vessel are given and the various and frequent mishaps of wind and wave detailed at length.  On January 8 an island was reached where the people “were afraid of our ship and of us and our weapons.  They are well proportioned, tall of stature, and bearded, their beards reaching to their waists.  The men wear their hair long like women, neatly combed and tied behind in a knot.  They are greedy, very treacherous, and thoroughly unprincipled....  They are Caribs, and, I understand, eat human flesh.  They are warlike, as it seemed to us, for they were always prepared, and they must carry on war with other islands.  Their weapons are spears pointed with fish bones, and masanas [a wooden weapon, generally edged with sharp flint, used by the early Mexican and Peruvian aborigines.]....  They are much given to hurling stones from slings, and with very accurate aim.  They are excellent swimmers and sailors.  We called this island Nadadores [Swimmers], because they swam out to us when we were more than a league from the island.”  A mutiny sprang up after reaching the Philippines, but was checked.  Arellano claims that he left the prescribed tokens of his visit in Mindanao.  The patache reached Puerto de la Navidad on August 9, after its crew had suffered many hardships and much sickness.  Legazpi, quite naturally, was much displeased at the evident desertion of the “San Lucas” and caused action to be taken against Arellano and Lope Martin, by Gabriel Diaz of the Mexican mint.  This latter presented various petitions before the Audiencia of Mexico, detailing the charges and asking investigation.  The charges were desertion,—­“in which the loss he occasioned cannot be overestimated,” because this vessel was intended for a close navigation of the islands and their rivers and estuaries, which the larger vessels could not attempt,—­assuming to himself powers of jurisdiction that belonged to Legazpi as general of the expedition,—­executing summary justice on two men (causing them to be thrown overboard),—­cruelty, and “many other grave and serious offenses;” which “he had committed in company with the pilot and others.”  Diaz asked that Arellano be made to render an account to Legazpi and to serve for his pay, as he had served in the expedition but ten days.  However just the demand for an investigation, it was never made,