Weymouth would descend the valley of the Thames once more.  It was of great importance if he found a great city at the tidal limit.  Going down the Thames and the Tay, they would find, at the last ford of one, the old Abbey of Westminster, and at the last ford of the other, the old Abbey of Scoon.  The kings of England and Scotland were crowned there because these were the most important places—­a point of great historic interest.  As a matter of practical interest, he might mention that Scoon and Westminster alike passed out of supreme importance when bridges were built across the river below; and he would next point out how just as Perth became of subordinate importance when the great Tay Bridge was built, so it became a tremendously important question to London, as it might in turn be much affected by the making of a great and a new bridge much further down the stream.  This study of the descending river had real and practical, as well as historical importance.  He had been about considerably in the great cities of the United States, and had been struck by the amount of good endeavour there.  It was not, however, by denouncing Tammany that they could beat it, but by understanding it.  They must understand the mechanism by which the Celtic chieftain ruled his clan, and they must deal with these methods by still other methods; and they might often find it more satisfactory to re-moralise the chieftain than to destroy him.

Professor Geddes concluded by saying that he appreciated the admirable suggestion of Mr. Still towards the evolution of civic unions.  He was sure Mr. Still had there an idea of great significance which might be developed.