tribute, or of his authority as lawful. It is
beyond doubt, that the question was captious, and that
the design of the Scribes and Pharisees, in proposing
it to Christ, was to have him ensnared in his words.
This they thought themselves sure of, whether he should
answer positively or negatively. For if positively,
and so recognize and acknowledge Caesar’s
title, then they would have occasion to accuse him
to the people, as an enemy to the laws, liberty and
honor, of the Jewish nation. This is evident
from ver. 26: “And they could not take
hold of his words before the people.” And
then, if he should deny that it was lawful, they would
have an opportunity or pretense of delating and delivering
him to the Roman governor, as an enemy to Caesar.
They seem, however, to have been confident, that he
who taught the way of God in truth, without regard
to any, would never inculcate it as a duty for them
to give tribute to Caesar, subjection to whom,
as their lawful governor, for conscience sake, was
so contrary to the divine law given to the Jews,
respecting their magistrates; and if so, they would
not miss of sufficient accusation against him.
But here infinite wisdom shone forth, in giving such
an answer as declared their wisdom to be but folly,
and at once disappointed all their malicious hopes;
an answer which left Caesar’s claim unresolved,
as to any positive determination whether it belonged
to him or not. The question is in direct terms.
Our Lord does not directly answer to the question,
in the terms proposed by the wicked spies. He
neither expressly says it is lawful or unlawful to
pay it, but gave his answer in such terms as they
could not from it form an accusation against him,
either to the people or to the governor. He, in
general, teaches to give Caesar all things
that, by the law of God, were due to him; at the same
time enjoining them that, under pretense of giving
to men their demands, they rob not God of what was
his due, namely, a conscientious regard to all the
laws he had given them, and universal obedience to
all his commands, without regard to persons of any
station. And it is certain, that Caesar
was a proud, aspiring, idolatrous and bloody usurper
(like the king of Babylon, Hab. ii, 5, for which
causes the Lord denounces fearful wrath and judgments
against him, Hab. ii, 7-14), having no other right
to the most part of his dominions, than the Lord’s
providential disposal, which sometimes makes “the
tabernacles of robbers prosper; into whose hand God
bringeth abundantly;” Job xii, 6. “And
for their sins gives Jacob to the spoil, and
Israel to the robbers;” Isa. xiii, 24.
“And giveth power to the beast, to continue forty
and two months, and to have power over all nations;”
Rev. xiii, 5, 7. So that, by looking into the
divine law, which determines every one’s due,
according to their just character, and of which they
could not be ignorant, they might see that he had