who had no grievance, and who listened with the facile indignation of the ignorant to the representations of these emissaries, subscribed their names as voters and constituents to a cause whose merits or demerits were quite uncomprehended by them.  The members of Congress receiving these memorials immediately set themselves in motion.  As Thorne could not officially reply to what had not as yet been officially urged, his hands were tied.  A clamour that had at first been merely noisy and meaningless, began now to gain an effect.

Thorne confessed himself puzzled.

“If it isn’t a case of a snowball growing bigger the farther it rolls, I can’t account for it,” said he.  “This thing ought to have died down long ago.  It’s been fomented very skilfully.  Such a campaign as this one against us takes both ability and money—­more of either than I thought Samuels could possibly possess.”

In the meantime, Erbe managed rapidly to tie up the legal aspects of the situation.  The case, as it developed, proved to be open-and-shut against his client, but apparently unaffected by the certainty of this, he persisted in the interposition of all sorts of delays.  Samuels continued to live undisturbed on his claim, which, as Thorne pointed out, had a bad moral effect on the community.

The issue soon took on a national aspect.  It began to be commented on by outside newspapers.  Publications close to the administration and thoroughly in sympathy with its forest policies, began gravely to doubt the advisability of pushing these debatable claims at present.

“They are of small value,” said one, “in comparison with the large public domain of which they are part.  At a time when the Forest Service is new in the saddle and as yet subjected to the most violent attacks by the special interests on the floors of Congress, it seems unwise to do anything that might tend to arouse public opinion against it.”

As though to give point to this, there now commenced in Congress that virulent assault led by some of the Western senators, aimed at the very life of the Service itself.  Allegations of dishonesty, incompetence, despotism; of depriving the public of its heritage; of the curtailments of rights and liberties; of folly; of fraud were freely brought forward and urged with impassioned eloquence.  Arguments special to cattlemen, to sheepmen, to lumbermen, to cordwood men, to pulp men, to power men were emphasized by all sorts of misstatements, twisted statements, or special appeals to greed, personal interest and individual policy.  To support their eloquence, senators supposedly respectable did not hesitate boldly to utter sweeping falsehoods of fact.  The Service was fighting for its very life.

Nevertheless, persistently, the officials proceeded with their investigations.  Bob had conducted his campaign so skilfully against Samuels that Thorne used him further in similar matters.  Little by little, indeed, the young man was withdrawn from other work.  He now spent many hours with Amy in the little office going over maps and files, over copies of documents and old records.  When he had thoroughly mastered the ins and outs of a case, he departed with his pack animal and saddle horse to look the ground over in person.