It is certain that these names were all known to the Government before, and that he was not betraying any secret.  Nevertheless the gentlemen in question were at once seized, imprisoned and fined, on the alleged evidence of Campion’s confessions only.  This of course caused much scandal among Catholics, and so long as he lay lost in the Tower dungeons, unpleasant rumours about his constancy could not be effectively contradicted.  Thus far Elizabeth’s ministers had gained an advantage, which Pounde had foretold they were likely to win.  But the remedy he had suggested also proved effective.

Though under ordinary circumstances Elizabeth’s ministers “meant nothing less” than having the disputation requested, nevertheless now that Campion was so terribly shaken and reduced, they hoped that they might arrange some sort of a meeting, which might in show correspond with what had been demanded in the Decem Rationes, and yet leave them with a certain victory.  They were emboldened too, by finding that their prisoner was not after all, such a particularly learned man.  He had never been a professor of theology, or written or made special studies, beyond the ordinary course which in those days was not a long one.  It was, therefore, settled that four disputations should be held in the Tower of London.  Theology was still taught at Oxford and Cambridge in something of the old mediaeval method and in syllogistic form.  The men who were pitted against Campion had lately been, or were still, examiners at the Universities.  Nor is it to be denied for a moment that they did their work well.  The attack never faltered.  Their own side quite believed they had won.  The method they adopted was this.  They assumed the role of examiners, and starting with the Decem Rationes before them, they plied Campion with crabbed texts, and obscure quotations from the Fathers.  Then they cut short his answers, and as soon as one had examined for one quarter of an hour, another took his place, for they were anxious above all things to avoid defeat.  The number of topics broached and left unsettled surpasses belief, indeed the scene was one of utter confusion, taunts, scoldings, sneers—­a very, very different test from the academic argumentation, which Campion had requested.

The martyr did not show any remarkable erudition, indeed all opportunity to do so was carefully shut off.  No University, I fancy, would have given him a chair of theology on the strength of his replies on that occasion.  There was more than one premature assertion of victory on the Protestant side.  But when the Catholic and Protestant accounts are compared, one sees that the advantages won against Campion were slight.  They evidently hoped that by vigorous and repeated attacks they would at last puzzle or bear him down.  But they were never near this.  He was always fresh and gay, never in difficulties, or at the end of his tether.  He stands out quite the noblest, the most sympathetic and important figure in those motley assemblies.  The Catholics were delighted.  They succeeded in getting their own report of the disputations, which is still extant, and they would have printed it, if they had been able.  Philip, Earl of Arundel, by far the most important convert of that generation, was won over by what he heard in those debates.