we may be unwilling to go to the lions. Our time
has its own trial—by no means unexacting
let me tell you—but we quietly slip it
by: it is much easier to revile the infidel.
This as a test of loyalty should be pinned: we
shall shut up thereby the hypocrite. And the
earnest man, more conscious of his own burden, will
be more sympathetic, generous and just, and will come
to be more logical and to see what Newman well remarked,
that one who asks questions shows he has no belief
and in asking may be but on the road to one.
If to ask a question is to express a doubt, it is no
less, perhaps, to seek a way out of it. “What
better can he do than inquire, if he is in doubt?”
asks Newman. “Not to inquire is in his case
to be satisfied with disbelief.” We should,
acting in this light, instead of denouncing the questioner,
answer his question freely and frankly, encourage him
to ask others and put him one or two by the way.
Men meeting in this manner may still remain on opposite
sides, but there will be formed between them a bond
of sympathy that mutual sincerity can never fail to
establish. This is freedom, and a fine beautiful
thing, surely worth a fine effort. What we have
grown accustomed to, the bitterness, the recriminations,
the persecutions and retaliations, are all the evil
weeds of prejudice, growing around our principles and
choking them. They are so far a denial of principle,
a proof of mental slavery. Our freedom will attest
to faith: “Where the Spirit of the Lord
is, there is Liberty.”
VIII
This, in conclusion, is the root of the matter:
to claim freedom and to allow it in like measure;
rather than to deny, to urge men to follow their beliefs:
only thus can they find salvation. To constrain
a man to profess what we profess is worse than delusion:
should he give lip service to what he does not hold
at heart, ’twere for him deceitful and for us
dangerous. Where his star calls, let him walk
sincerely. If his creed is insufficient or inconsistent,
in his struggle he shall test it, and in his sincerity
he must make up the insufficiency or remove the inconsistency.
This is the only course for honourable men and no man
should object. To repeat, it puts an equal burden
on all—the onus of justifying the faith
that is in them. Life is a divine adventure and
he whose faith is finest, firmest and clearest will
go farthest. God does not hold his honours for
the timid: the man who buried his talent, fearing
to lose it, was cast into exterior darkness. He
who will step forward fearlessly will be justified.
“All things are possible to him who believeth.”
Many on both sides may be surprised to find suddenly
proposed as a test to both sides the readiness to adventure
bravely on the Sea of Life. The free-thinker
may be astonished to hear, not that he goes too far,
but does not go far enough. He may gasp at the
test, but it is in effect the test and the only true