Heaven forefend that I should use a pen that should be ever dedicated to an exposition of unalterable moral principle to transcribe Mrs. Tretherick’s own theory of this interval and episode, with its feeble palliations, its illogical deductions, its fond excuses, and weak apologies.  It would seem, however, that her experience had been hard.  Her slender stock of money was soon exhausted.  At Sacramento she found that the composition of verse, although appealing to the highest emotions of the human heart, and compelling the editorial breast to the noblest commendation in the editorial pages, was singularly inadequate to defray the expenses of herself and Carry.  Then she tried the stage, but failed signally.  Possibly her conception of the passions was different from that which obtained with a Sacramento audience; but it was certain that her charming presence, so effective at short range, was not sufficiently pronounced for the footlights.  She had admirers enough in the greenroom, but awakened no abiding affection among the audience.  In this strait, it occurred to her that she had a voice—­a contralto of no very great compass or cultivation, but singularly sweet and touching; and she finally obtained position in a church choir.  She held it for three months, greatly to her pecuniary advantage, and, it is said, much to the satisfaction of the gentlemen in the back pews, who faced toward her during the singing of the last hymn.

I remember her quite distinctly at this time.  The light that slanted through the oriel of St. Dives’s choir was wont to fall very tenderly on her beautiful head with its stacked masses of deerskin-colored hair, on the low black arches of her brows, and to deepen the pretty fringes that shaded her eyes of Genoa velvet.  Very pleasant it was to watch the opening and shutting of that small straight mouth, with its quick revelation of little white teeth, and to see the foolish blood faintly deepen her satin cheek as you watched.  For Mrs. Tretherick was very sweetly conscious of admiration and, like most pretty women, gathered herself under your eye like a racer under the spur.

And then, of course, there came trouble.  I have it from the soprano—­a little lady who possessed even more than the usual unprejudiced judgment of her sex—­that Mrs. Tretherick’s conduct was simply shameful; that her conceit was unbearable; that, if she considered the rest of the choir as slaves, she (the soprano) would like to know it; that her conduct on Easter Sunday with the basso had attracted the attention of the whole congregation; and that she herself had noticed Dr. Cope twice look up during the service; that her (the soprano’s) friends had objected to her singing in the choir with a person who had been on the stage, but she had waived this.  Yet she had it from the best authority that Mrs. Tretherick had run away from her husband, and that this red-haired child who sometimes came in the choir was not her own.  The tenor confided to me behind the organ