the trees are eaten away to within four feet of the
ground. Then the animals who happen to be an
inch or two short of the average will die of starvation.
All the animals who happen to be an inch or so above
the average will be better fed and stronger than the
others. They will secure the strongest and tallest
mates; and their progeny will survive whilst the average
ones and the sub-average ones will die out. This
process, by which the species gains, say, an inch in
reach, will repeat itself until the giraffe’s
neck is so long that he can always find food enough
within his reach, at which point, of course, the selective
process stops and the length of the giraffe’s
neck stops with it. Otherwise, he would grow
until he could browse off the trees in the moon.
And this, mark you, without the intervention of any
stockbreeder, human or divine, and without will, purpose,
design, or even consciousness beyond the blind will
to satisfy hunger. It is true that this blind
will, being in effect a will to live, gives away the
whole case; but still, as compared to the open-eyed
intelligent wanting and trying of Lamarck, the Darwinian
process may be described as a chapter of accidents.
As such, it seems simple, because you do not at first
realize all that it involves. But when its whole
significance dawns on you, your heart sinks into a
heap of sand within you. There is a hideous fatalism
about it, a ghastly and damnable reduction of beauty
and intelligence, of strength and purpose, of honor
and aspiration, to such casually picturesque changes
as an avalanche may make in a mountain landscape,
or a railway accident in a human figure. To call
this Natural Selection is a blasphemy, possible to
many for whom Nature is nothing but a casual aggregation
of inert and dead matter, but eternally impossible
to the spirits and souls of the righteous. If
it be no blasphemy, but a truth of science, then the
stars of heaven, the showers and dew, the winter and
summer, the fire and heat, the mountains and hills,
may no longer be called to exalt the Lord with us by
praise; their work is to modify all things by blindly
starving and murdering everything that is not lucky
enough to survive in the universal struggle for hogwash.
THE BRINK OF THE BOTTOMLESS PIT
Thus did the neck of the giraffe reach out across the whole heavens and make men believe that what they saw there was a gloaming of the gods. For if this sort of selection could turn an antelope into a giraffe, it could conceivably turn a pond full of amoebas into the French Academy. Though Lamarck’s way, the way of life, will, aspiration, and achievement, remained still possible, this newly shewn way of hunger, death, stupidity, delusion, chance, and bare survival was also possible: was indeed most certainly the way in which many apparently intelligently designed transformations had actually come to pass. Had I not preluded with the apparently idle story of my