Must he always tamely submit to the fetters which bound him?  Could he do nothing to free himself?  Could the law do nothing?  Enquiry—­violent action of some sort—­rebellion against the conditions which had grown so rigid about him:—­for the hundredth time, he canvassed all ways of escape, and for the hundredth time, found none.

He knew very well what was wrong with him.  It was simply the imperious need for a woman’s companionship in his life—­for love.  Physically and morally, the longing which had lately taken possession of him, was becoming a gnawing and perpetual distress.  There was the plain fact.  This hour with Cynthia Welwyn had stirred in him the depths of old pain.  But he was not really in love with Cynthia.  During the war, amid the absorption of his work, and the fierce pressure of the national need, he had been quite content to forget her.  His work—­and England’s strait—­had filled his mind and his time.  Except for certain dull resentments and regrets, present at all times in the background of consciousness, the four years of the war had been to him a period of relief, almost of deliverance.  He had been able to lose himself; and in that inner history of the soul which is the real history of each one of us, that had been for long years impossible.

But now all that protection and help was gone; the floodgates were loosened again.  His work still went on; but it was no longer absorbing; it no longer mattered enough to hold in check the vague impulses and passions that were beating against his will.

And meanwhile the years were running on.  He was forty-four, Helena Pitstone’s guardian, and clearly relegated already by that unmanageable child to the ranks of the middle-aged.  He had read her thought in her great scornful eyes.  “What has your generation to do with mine?  Your day is over!”

And all the while the ugly truth was that he had never had his “day”—­and was likely now to miss it for good.  Or at least such “day” as had shone upon him had been so short, so chequered, so tragically wiped out, it might as well never have dawned.  Yet the one dear woman friend to whom in these latter years he had spoken freely, who knew him through and through—­Helena Pitstone’s mother—­had taken for granted, in her quiet ascetic way, that he had indeed had his chance, and must accept for good and all what had come of it.  It was because she thought of him as set apart, as debarred by what had happened to him, from honest love-making, and protected by his own nature from anything less, that she had asked him to take charge of Helena.  He realized it now.  It had been the notion of a fanciful idealist, springing from certain sickroom ideas of sacrifice—­renunciation—­submission to the will of God—­and so forth.

It was not the will of God!—­that he should live forsaken and die forlorn!  He hurled defiance, even at Rachel, his dear dead friend, who had been so full of pity for him, and for whom he had felt the purest and most unselfish affection he had ever known—­since his mother’s death.