Mr. Bonsal out-Spaniards the Spaniards themselves as regards both their numbers and their loss.  These points are discussed elsewhere.  He develops for the Spanish side, to account for their retreat, a wholly new explanation—­viz., that they retreated because they saw reinforcements arriving for the Americans.  The Spaniards themselves make no such claim.  Lieutenant Tejeiro asserts that they retreated because news had come of a (wholly mythical) American advance on Morro Castle.  The Spanish official report simply says that the Americans were repulsed; which is about as accurate a statement as the other two.  All three explanations, those by General Rubin, by Lieutenant Tejeiro, and by Mr. Bonsal alike, are precisely on a par with the first Spanish official report of the battle of Manila Bay, in which Admiral Dewey was described as having been repulsed and forced to retire.

There are one or two minor mistakes made by Mr. Bonsal.  He states that on the roster of the officers of the Rough Riders there were ten West Pointers.  There were three, one of whom resigned.  Only two were in the fighting.  He also states that after Las Guasimas Brigadier-General Young was made a Major-General and Colonel Wood a Brigadier-General, while the commanding officers of the First and Tenth Cavalry were ignored in this “shower of promotions.”  In the first place, the commanding officers of the First and Tenth Cavalry were not in the fight—­only one squadron of each having been present.  In the next place, there was no “shower of promotions” at all.  Nobody was promoted except General Young, save to fill the vacancies caused by death or by the promotion of General Young.  Wood was not promoted because of this fight.  General Young most deservedly was promoted.  Soon after the fight he fell sick.  The command of the brigade then fell upon Wood, simply because he had higher rank than the other two regimental commanders of the brigade; and I then took command of the regiment exactly as Lieutenant-Colonels Veile and Baldwin had already taken command of the First and Tenth Cavalry when their superior officers were put in charge of brigades.  After the San Juan fighting, in which Wood commanded a brigade, he was made a Brigadier-General and I was then promoted to the nominal command of the regiment, which I was already commanding in reality.

Mr. Bonsal’s claim of superior efficiency for the colored regular regiments as compared with the white regular regiments does not merit discussion.  He asserts that General Wheeler brought on the Guasimas fight in defiance of orders.  Lieutenant Miley, in his book, “In Cuba with Shafter,” on page 83, shows that General Wheeler made his fight before receiving the order which it is claimed he disobeyed.  General Wheeler was in command ashore; he was told to get in touch with the enemy, and, being a man with the “fighting edge,” this meant that he was certain to fight.  No general who was worth his salt would have failed to fight under such conditions; the only question would be as to how the fight was to be made.  War means fighting; and the soldier’s cardinal sin is timidity.