All thinking is a fining down of one’s ideas, and thus far we have come to the statement of Ireland’s second question.  It is not Catholic or Nationalist, nor have I said that it is entirely Protestant and Unionist, but it is on the extreme wing of this latter party that responsibility must be laid.  It is difficult, even for an Irishman living in Ireland, to come on the real political fact which underlies Irish Protestant politics, and which fact has consistently opposed and baffled every attempt made by either England or Ireland to come to terms.  There is such a fact, and clustered around it is a body of men whose hatred of their country is persistent and deadly and unexplained.

One may make broad generalisations on the apparent situation and endeavour to solve it by those.  We may say that loyalty to England is the true centre of their action.  I will believe it, but only to a point.  Loyalty to England does not inevitably include this active hatred, this blindness, this withering of all sympathy for the people among whom one is born, and among whom one has lived in peace, for they have lived in peace amongst us.  We may say that it is due to the idea of privilege and the desire for power.  Again, I will accept it up to a point—­but these are cultural obsessions, and they cease to act when the breaking-point is reached.

I know of only two mental states which are utterly without bowels or conscience.  These are cowardice and greed.  Is it to a synthesis of these states that this more than mortal enmity may be traced?  What do they fear, and what is it they covet?  What can they redoubt in a country which is practically crimeless, or covet in a land that is almost as bare as a mutton bone?  They have mesmerised themselves, these men, and have imagined into our quiet air brigands and thugs and titans, with all the other notabilities of a tale for children.

I do not think that this either will tell the tale, but I do think there is a story to be told—­I imagine an esoteric wing to the Unionist Party.  I imagine that Party includes a secret organisation—­they may be Orangemen, they may be Masons, and, if there be such, I would dearly like to know what the metaphysic of their position is, and how they square it with any idea of humanity or social life.  Meantime, all this is surmise, and I, as a novelist, have a notoriously flighty imagination, and am content to leave it at that.

But this secondary Irish question is not so terrible as it appears.  It is terrible now, it would not be terrible if Ireland had national independence.

The great protection against a lie is—­not to believe it; and Ireland, in this instance, has that protection.  The claims made by the Unionist Wing do not rely solely on the religious base.  They use all the arguments.  It is, according to them, unsafe to live in Ireland. (Let us leave this insurrection of a week out of the question.) Life is not safe in Ireland.  Property shivers in terror of daily or nightly appropriation.  Other, undefined, but even more woeful glooms and creeps, wriggle stealthily abroad.