having regard to the feelings under which we acted,
think you is it a true charge that we had for our
intent and object the bringing of the administration
of justice into contempt? Does a man, by protesting,
ever so vehemently, against an act of a not infallible
tribunal, incur the charge of attempting its overthrow?
What evidence can be shown to you that we uttered
a word against the general character of the administration
of justice in this country, while denouncing this
particular proceeding, which we say was a fearful
failure of justice—a horrible blunder,
a terrible act of passion! None—none.
I say, for myself, I sincerely believe that in this
country of ours justice is administered by the judges
of the Irish Bench with a purity and impartiality
between man and man not to be surpassed in the
universal world. Let me not be thought to cast
reflection on this court, or the learned judges
before whom I now stand, if I except in a certain
sense, and on some occasions, political trials
between the subject and the crown. Apart from
this, I fearlessly say the bench of justice in
Ireland fully enjoys and is worthy of respect and
homage. I care not from what political party
its members be drawn, I say that, with hardly an
exception, when robed with the ermine, they become
dead to the world of politics, and sink the politician
in the loftier character of representative of Sacred
Justice. Yet, gentlemen, holding those views,
I would, nevertheless, protest against and denounce
such a trial as that in Manchester, if it had taken
place here in Ireland. For, what we contend
is that the men in Manchester would never have been
found guilty on such evidence, would never have
been executed on such a verdict, if time had been
given to let panic and passion pass away—time
to let English good sense and calm reason and, sense
of justice have sway. Now, gentlemen, judge
ye me on this whole case; for I have done.
I have spoken at great length, but I plead not merely
my own cause but the cause of my country. For
myself I care little. I stand before you here
with the manacles, I might say, on my hands.
Already a prison cell awaits me in Kilmainham.
My doom, in any event, is sealed. Already
a conviction has been obtained against me for my
opinions on this same event; for it is not one arrow
alone that has been shot from the crown office
quiver at me—at my reputation, my property,
my liberty. In a few hours more my voice will
be silenced; but before the world is shut out from
me for a term, I appeal to your verdict—to
the verdict of my fellow-citizens—of
my fellow-countrymen—to judge my life, my
conduct, my acts, my principles and say am I a criminal.
Sedition, in a rightly ordered community, is indeed
a crime. But who is it that challenges me?
Who is it that demands my loyalty? Who is it that
calls out to me, “Oh, ingrate son, where is
the filial affection, the respect, the obedience,
the support, that is my due? Unnatural, seditious,
and rebellious child, a dungeon shall punish your crime!”