were sentenced, thirty newspaper reporters sent
up to the Home Secretary a petition protesting
that—the evidence of the witnesses and the
verdict of the jury notwithstanding—there
was at least one innocent man thus marked for execution.
The government felt that the reporters were right and
the jurors wrong. They pardoned Maguire as
an innocent man—that same Maguire whose
legal conviction is here put in as evidence that he
and four others were truly murderers, to sympathise
with whom is to commit sedition—nay,
“to glorify the cause of murder.”
Well, after that, our minds were easy. We
considered it out of the question any man would
be hanged on a verdict thus ruined, blasted, and abandoned;
and believing those men innocent of murder, though
guilty of another most serious legal crime—rescue
with violence, and incidental, though not intentional
loss of life—we rejoiced that a terrible
mistake was, as we thought, averted. But now arose
in redoubled fury the savage cry for blood.
In vain good men, noble and humane men, in England
tried to save the national honour by breasting this
horrible outburst of passion. They were overborne.
Petitioners for mercy were mobbed and hooted in
the streets. We saw all this—we saw
all this; and think you it did not sink into our hearts?
Fancy if you can our feelings when we heard that
yet another man out of five was respited—ah,
he was an American, gentlemen—an American,
not an Irishman—but that the three Irishmen,
Allen, Larkin, and O’Brien, were to die—were
to be put to death on a verdict and on evidence that
would not hang a dog in England! We refused to
the last to credit it; and thus incredulous, deemed
it idle to make any effort to save their lives.
But it was true; it was deadly true. And then,
gentlemen, the doomed three appeared in a new character.
Then they rose into the dignity and heroism of
martyrs. The manner in which they bore themselves
through the dreadful ordeal ennobled them for ever
It was then we all learned to love and revere them
as patriots and Christians. Oh, gentlemen,
it is only at this point I feel my difficulty in
addressing you whose religious faith is not that which
is mine. For it is only Catholics who can understand
the emotions aroused in Catholic hearts by conduct
such as theirs in that dreadful hour. Catholics
alone can understand how the last solemn declarations
of such men, after receiving the last sacraments
of the Church, and about to meet their Great Judge
face to face, can outweigh the reckless evidence
of Manchester thieves and pickpockets. Yes; in
that hour they told us they were innocent, but
were ready to die; and we believed them. We
believe them still. Aye, do we! They did
not go to meet their God with a falsehood on their
lips. On that night before their execution,
oh, what a scene! What a picture did England present
at the foot of the Manchester scaffold! The
brutal populace thronged thither in tens of thousands.
They danced; they sang; they blasphemed; they chorused