we should remember that they are a people old in war,
very strict in military etiquette, and apt to take
fire when others scarcely seem warmed. Permit
me to recommend, in the most particular manner, the
cultivation of harmony and good agreement, and your
endeavor to destroy that ill-humor which may have got
into officers.” To Lafayette he wrote:
“Everybody, sir, who reasons, will acknowledge
the advantages which we have derived from the French
fleet, and the zeal of the commander of it; but in
a free and republican government you cannot restrain
the voice of the multitude. Every man will speak
as he thinks, or, more properly, without thinking,
and consequently will judge of effects without attending
to the causes. The censures which have been leveled
at the French fleet would more than probably have
fallen in a much higher degree upon a fleet of our
own, if we had had one in the same situation.
It is the nature of man to be displeased with everything
that disappoints a favorite hope or flattering project;
and it is the folly of too many of them to condemn
without investigating circumstances.” Finally
he wrote to D’Estaing, deploring the difference
which had arisen, mentioning his own efforts and wishes
to restore harmony, and said: “It is in
the trying circumstances to which your Excellency
has been exposed that the virtues of a great mind
are displayed in their brightest lustre, and that
a general’s character is better known than in
the moment of victory. It was yours by every
title that can give it; and the adverse elements that
robbed you of your prize can never deprive you of
the glory due you. Though your success has not
been equal to your expectations, yet you have the
satisfaction of reflecting that you have rendered
essential services to the common cause.”
This is not the letter of a dull man. Indeed,
there is a nicety about it that partakes of cleverness,
a much commoner thing than greatness, but something
which all great men by no means possess. Thus
by tact and comprehension of human nature, by judicious
suppression and equally judicious letters, Washington,
through the prudent exercise of all his commanding
influence, quieted his own people and soothed his allies.
In this way a serious disaster was averted, and an
abortive expedition was all that was left to be regretted,
instead of an ugly quarrel, which might readily have
neutralized the vast advantages flowing from the French
alliance. Having refitted, D’Estaing bore
away for the West Indies, and so closed the first
chapter in the history of the alliance with France.
Nothing more was heard of the allies until the spring
was well advanced, when M. Gerard, the minister, wrote,
intimating that D’Estaing was about to return,
and asking what we would do. Washington replied
at length, professing his willingness to cooeperate
in any way, and offering, if the French would send
ships, to abandon everything, run all risks, and make
an attack on New York. Nothing further came of