“How much longer will it be before even thoughts become criminal in Germany?  Mehring is one of the most brilliant historians and writers, and one of the first representatives of German intellectual life—­known as such far beyond the German frontiers.  When it is now known abroad that such a man has been put under a sort of preventive arrest merely in order to cut him off from the public for political reasons, one really cannot be astonished at the low reputation enjoyed by the German Government both at home and abroad.  How evil must be the state of a Government which has to lock up the first minds of the country in order to choke their opposition!”

Herr Dittmann’s second case was that of Frau Rosa Luxemburg.  He said that she was put under arrest many months ago, without any charge being made against her, and merely out of fear of her intellectual influence upon the working classes.  All the Socialist women of Germany were deeply indignant, and he invited the Government to consider that such things must make it the positive duty of Socialists in France, England, Italy and Russia “to fight against a Government which imprisons without any reason the best-known champions of the International proletariat.”  The treatment of both Mehring and Frau Luxemburg had been terrible.  The former, old and ill, had had the greatest difficulty in getting admission to a prison infirmary.  Frau Luxemburg a month ago was taken from her prison bed in the middle of the night, removed to the police headquarters, and put in a cell which was reserved for prostitutes.  She had not been allowed a doctor, and had been given food which she could not eat.  Just before the Reichstag debate she had been, taken away from Berlin to Wronke, in the Province of Posen.

Herr Dittmann then gave a terrible account, some of it unfit for reproduction, of the treatment in prison of two girls of eighteen whose offence was that on June 27th they had distributed invitations to working women to attend a meeting of protest against the procedure in the case of Herr Liebknecht.  He observed that they owed it entirely to themselves and to their training if they had not been ruined physically and morally in their “royal Prussian prison.”  When they were at last released they were informed that they would be imprisoned for the rest of the war if they attended any public meeting.  Herr Dittmann proceeded:—­

“Here we have police brutality in all its purity.  This is how a working-class child who is trying to make her way up to knowledge and Kultur is treated in the country of the promised ’new orientation,’ in which (according to the Imperial Chancellor) ’the road is to be opened for all who are efficient.’  These are the methods by which the spirit of independence is systematically to be billed.  That is the reason for the arrests of members of the Socialist party who stand on the side of determined opposition.  You imagine that by isolating the leading elements of the opposition you can crush the head of the snake.”