shall become navigable, and a vast land or New World
shall be discovered.” St Gregory, in his
exposition of the Epistle of St Clement, says, “There
is a new world, or even worlds, beyond the ocean.”
We are informed by other authors, that a Carthaginian
merchant ship accidentally discovered in the ocean,
many days sail from our ancient continent, an incredibly
fruitful island, full of navigable rivers, having plenty
of wild beasts, but uninhabited by men, and that the
discoverers were desirous of settling there; but,
having given an account of this discovery to the senate
of Carthage, they not only absolutely prohibited any
one to sail thither, but put all who had been there
to death, the more effectually to prevent any others
from making the attempt. Yet all this is nothing
to the purpose, as there is no authentic memorial of
this supposed voyage, and those who have spoken of
it incidentally have given no cosmographical indications
of its situation, by means of which the admiral Christopher
Columbus, who made the first discovery of the West
Indies, could have acquired any information to guide
him in that great discovery. Besides, that there
were no wild beasts, either in the windward or leeward
islands which he discovered, those men who would rob
Columbus, in part at least, of the honour of his great
discovery, misapply the following quotation from the
Timaeus of Plato: “There is no sailing
upon the ocean, because its entrance is shut up by
the Pillars of Hercules. Yet there had formerly
been an island in that ocean, larger than all Europe,
Asia, and Africa in one; and from thence a passage
to other islands, for such as went in search of them,
and from these other inlands people might go to all
the opposite continent, near the true ocean.”
These detractors from the honour of Columbus, in explaining
the words of Plato after their own manner, evince
more wit than truth, when they insist that the shut
up passage is the strait of Gibraltar, the gulf the
great ocean, the great island Atlantis, the
other islands beyond that the leeward and windward
islands, the continent opposite them the land of Peru,
and the true ocean the great South Sea, so called
from its vast extent. It is certain that no one
had any clear knowledge of these matters: and
what they now allege consists merely of notions and
guesses, patched together since the actual discovery;
for the ancients concluded there was no possibility
of sailing across the ocean on account of its vast
extent. These men, however, labour to confirm
their opinions, by alleging that the ancients possessed
much knowledge of the torrid zone; as they insit that
Hano the Carthaginian coasted round Africa, from the
straits of Gibraltar to the Red Sea, and that Eudoxias
navigated in the contrary direction from the Red Sea
to the Mediterranean. They allege farther, that
both Ovid and Pliny make mention of the island of
Trapobano, now Zumatra[2] which is under the
line.