“What a spectacle!” says the master to himself, as he looks at this sad display.  “What shall I do?” The first impulse is to break forth upon them at once with all the artillery of reproof, and threatening, and punishment.  I have seen, in such a case, a scolding and frowning master walk up and down before such a class with a stern and angry air, commanding this one to stand back, and that one to come forward, ordering one boy to put down his book, and scolding at a second for having lost his place, and knocking the knees of another with his ruler because he was out of the line.  The boys scowl at their teacher, and, with ill-natured reluctance, they obey just enough to escape punishment.

Another teacher looks calmly at the scene, and says to himself, “What shall I do to remove effectually these evils?  If I can but interest the boys in reform, it will be far more easy to effect it than if I attempt to accomplish it by the mere exercise of my authority.”

In the mean time things go on during the reading in their own way.  The teacher simply observes.  He is in no haste to commence his operations.  He looks for the faults; watches, without seeming to watch, the movements which he is attempting to control.  He studies the materials with which he is to work, and lets their true character develop itself.  He tries to find something to approve in the exercise as it proceeds, and endeavors to interest the class by narrating some fact connected with the reading, or making some explanation which interests the boys.  At the end of the exercise he addresses them, perhaps, as follows: 

“I have observed, boys, in some military companies, that the officers are very strict, requiring implicit and precise obedience.  The men are required to form a precise line.” (Here there is a sort of involuntary movement all along the line, by which it is very sensibly straightened.) “They make all the men stand erect” (at this word heads go up, and straggling feet draw in all along the class), “in the true military posture.  They allow nothing to be done in the ranks but to attend to the exercise” (John hastily crowds his apple into his pocket), “and thus they regulate every thing in exact and steady discipline, so that all things go on in a most systematic and scientific manner.  This discipline is so admirable in some countries, especially in Europe, where much greater attention is paid to military tactics than in our country, that I have heard it said by travelers that some of the soldiers who mount guard at public places look as much like statues as they do like living men.

“Other commanders act differently.  They let the men do pretty much as they please.  So you will see such a company lounging into a line when the drum beats, as if they took little interest in what was going on.  While the captain is giving his commands, one is eating his luncheon, another is talking with his next neighbor.  Part are out of the line; part lounge on one foot; they hold their guns in every position; and, on the whole, present a very disorderly and unsoldier-like appearance.