The Common Council was mildly amused at the idea of putting public property to such an absurd, such an unheard-of use.  A few of the men were indignant.  One Germanic alderman exploded wrathfully:  “Vot does vimmens know about poys’ play?—­No!” And that settled it.

The committee went to the Board of Education once more, this time with better success.  They received permission to open and conduct, during the long vacation, one playground in a large schoolyard.  For two summers the women maintained that playground, holding their faith against the opposition of the janitors, the jeers of the newspapers, and the constant hostility of tax-payers, who protested against the “ruin of school property.”  After two years the Board of Education took over the work.  The mayor became personally interested, and the Common Council gracefully surrendered.  They have plenty of playgrounds in Detroit now, the latest development being winter sports.

If the Germanic alderman who protested that “vimmins” did not know anything about boys’ play was in office at the time, one wonders what his emotions were when the playgrounds committee first appeared before the Council and asked to have vacant lots flooded to give children skating ponds in winter.  Of course the Council refused.  Fire plugs were for water in case of fire, not for children’s enjoyment.  In fact there was a city ordinance forbidding the opening of a fire plug in winter, except to extinguish fire.  It took two years of constant work on the part of the club women to remove that ordinance, but they did it, and the children of Detroit have their winter as well as their summer playgrounds.

[Illustration:  Captain ball on girl’s field, Washington park, Pittsburgh.  Out of the persistent work of club women more than three hundred playgrounds for children have been established.]

In Philadelphia are fourteen splendid playgrounds and vacation schools, established in the beginning and maintained for many years by a civic club of women, the largest women’s civic club in the country.  The process of educating public opinion in their favor was slow, for it is difficult to make men see that the children of a modern city have different needs from the country or village children of a generation ago.  Men remember their own boyhood, and scoff at the idea of organized and supervised play in a made playground.  Women have no memories of the old swimming-hole.  They simply see the conditions before them, and they instinctively know what must be done to meet them.  The process of educating the others is slow, but this year in Philadelphia sixty public schoolyards were opened for public playgrounds, and the city appropriated five thousand dollars towards their maintenance.  In a hundred cities East and West the women’s clubs have been the original movers or have co-operated in the playground movement.