difficulty, arising out of an affair upon which, as
it has relations with the history of Sterne’s
literary work, it would be impossible, even in the
most strictly critical and least general of biographies,
to observe complete silence. I refer, of course,
to the famous and furious flirtation with Mrs. Draper—the
Eliza of the Yorick and Eliza Letters. Of the
affair itself but little need be said. I have
already stated my own views on the general subject
of Sterne’s love affairs; and I feel no inducement
to discuss the question of their innocence or otherwise
in relation to this particular amourette. I will
only say that were it technically as innocent as you
please, the mean which must be found between Thackeray’s
somewhat too harsh and Mr. Fitzgerald’s considerably
too indulgent judgment on it will lie, it seems to
me, decidedly nearer to the former than to the latter’s
extreme. This episode of violently sentimental
philandering with an Indian “grass widow”
was, in any case, an extremely unlovely passage in
Sterne’s life. On the best and most charitable
view of it, the flirtation, pursued in the way it
was, and to the lengths to which it was carried, must
be held to convict the elderly lover of the most deplorable
levity, vanity, indiscretion, and sickly sentimentalism.
It was, to say the least of it, most unbecoming in
a man of Sterne’s age and profession; and when
it is added that Yorick’s attentions to Eliza
were paid in so open a fashion as to be brought by
gossip to the ears of his neglected wife, then living
many hundred miles away from him, its highly reprehensible
character seems manifest enough in all ways.
No sooner, however, had the fascinating widow set
sail, than the sentimental lover began to feel so
strongly the need of a female consoler, that his heart
seems to have softened, insensibly, even towards his
wife. “I am unhappy,” he writes plaintively
to Lydia Sterne. “Thy mother and thyself
at a distance from me—and what can compensate
for such a destitution? For God’s sake persuade
her to come and fix in England! for life is too short
to waste in separation; and while she lives in one
country and I in another, many people will suppose
it proceeds from choice”—a supposition,
he seems to imply, which even my scrupulously discreet
conduct in her absence scarcely suffices to refute.
“Besides”—a word in which there
is here almost as much virtue as in an “if”—“I
want thee near me, thou child and darling of my heart.
I am in a melancholy mood, and my Lydia’s eyes
will smart with weeping when I tell her the cause that
just now affects me.” And then his sensibilities
brim over, and into his daughter’s ear he pours
forth his lamentations over the loss of her mother’s
rival. “I am apprehensive the dear friend
I mentioned in my last letter is going into a decline.
I was with her two days ago, and I never beheld a
being so altered. She has a tender frame, and
looks like a drooping lily, for the roses are fled
from her cheeks. I can never see or talk to this