of Wit, shall nevertheless give you a far greater
and more lasting Satisfaction: Just so it is in
a Picture that is smartly touched but not well studied;
one may call it a witty Picture, tho the Painter
in the mean time may be in Danger of being called
a Fool. On the other hand, a Picture that is thoroughly
understood in the Whole, and well performed in the
Particulars, that is begun on the Foundation of
Geometry, carried on by the Rules of Perspective,
Architecture, and Anatomy, and perfected by a good
Harmony, a just and natural Colouring, and such Passions
and Expressions of the Mind as are almost peculiar
to Raphael; this is what you may justly style
a wise Picture, and which seldom fails to strike
us Dumb, till we can assemble all our Faculties to
make but a tolerable Judgment upon it. Other
Pictures are made for the Eyes only, as Rattles
are made for Children’s Ears; and certainly that
Picture that only pleases the Eye, without representing
some well-chosen Part of Nature or other, does but
shew what fine Colours are to be sold at the Colour-shop,
and mocks the Works of the Creator. If the best
Imitator of Nature is not to be esteemed the best
Painter, but he that makes the greatest Show and
Glare of Colours; it will necessarily follow, that
he who can array himself in the most gaudy Draperies
is best drest, and he that can speak loudest the
best Orator. Every Man when he looks on a Picture
should examine it according to that share of Reason
he is Master of, or he will be in Danger of making
a wrong Judgment. If Men as they walk abroad
would make more frequent Observations on those Beauties
of Nature which every Moment present themselves
to their View, they would be better Judges when they
saw her well imitated at home: This would help
to correct those Errors which most Pretenders fall
into, who are over hasty in their Judgments, and
will not stay to let Reason come in for a share in
the Decision. Tis for want of this that Men
mistake in this Case, and in common Life, a wild
extravagant Pencil for one that is truly bold and
great, an impudent Fellow for a Man of true Courage
and Bravery, hasty and unreasonable Actions for
Enterprizes of Spirit and Resolution, gaudy Colouring
for that which is truly beautiful, a false and insinuating
Discourse for simple Truth elegantly recommended.
The Parallel will hold through all the Parts of
Life and Painting too; and the Virtuosos above-mentioned
will be glad to see you draw it with your Terms
of Art. As the Shadows in Picture represent the
serious or melancholy, so the Lights do the bright
and lively Thoughts: As there should be but
one forcible Light in a Picture which should catch
the Eye and fall on the Hero, so there should be
but one Object of our Love, even the Author of Nature.
These and the like Reflections well improved, might
very much contribute to open the Beauty of that Art,
and prevent young People from being poisoned by the
ill Gusto of an extravagant Workman that should
be imposed upon us. I am, SIR, Your most humble
Servant.
Mr. SPECTATOR,