Wordsworth still retained his ardent faith in the Revolution, and was even ready, though no better than “a landsman on the deck of a ship struggling with a hideous storm,” to make common cause with the Girondists.  But the prudence of friends at home forced him back to England before the beginning of the terrible year of ’93.  With his return closed that first survey of its inheritance, which most serious souls are wont to make in the fervid prime of early manhood.

It would be idle to attempt any commentary on the bare facts that we have just recapitulated; for Wordsworth himself has clothed them with their full force and meaning in the Prelude.  This record of the growth of a poet’s mind, told by the poet himself with all the sincerity of which he was capable, is never likely to be popular.  Of that, as of so much more of his poetry, we must say that, as a whole, it has not the musical, harmonious, sympathetic quality which seizes us in even the prose of such a book as Rousseau’s Confessions.  Macaulay thought the Prelude a poorer and more tiresome Excursion, with the old flimsy philosophy about the effect of scenery on the mind, the old crazy mystical metaphysics, and the endless wilderness of twaddle; still he admits that there are some fine descriptions and energetic declamations.  All Macaulay’s tastes and habits of mind made him a poor judge of such a poet as Wordsworth.  He valued spirit, energy, pomp, stateliness of form and diction, and actually thought Dryden’s fine lines about to-morrow being falser than the former clay equal to any eight lines in Lucretius.  But his words truly express the effect of the Prelude on more vulgar minds than his own.  George Eliot, on the other hand, who had the inward eye that was not among Macaulay’s gifts, found the Prelude full of material for a daily liturgy, and it is easy to imagine how she fondly lingered, as she did, over such a thought as this—­

                      “There is
  One great society alone on earth: 
  The noble Living and the noble Dead.”

There is, too, as may be found imbedded even in Wordsworth’s dullest work, many a line of the truest poetical quality, such as that on Newton’s statue in the silent Chapel of Trinity College—­

“The marble index of a mind for ever
Voyaging through strange seas of Thought alone.”

Apart, however, from beautiful lines like this, and from many noble passages of high reflection set to sonorous verse, this remarkable poem is in its whole effect unique in impressive power, as a picture of the advance of an elect and serious spirit from childhood and school-time, through the ordeal of adolescence, through close contact with stirring and enormous events, to that decisive stage when it has found the sources of its strength, and is fully and finally prepared to put its temper to the proof.