In this labyrinth of contradictory figures and statements, the deficit alone came out clearly.  M. de Brienne promised important economies, the Assembly voted a loan:  they were not willing to accept the responsibility of the important reforms demanded by the king.  The speeches were long and vague, the objections endless.  All the schemes of imposts were censured one after the other.  “We leave it to the king’s wisdom,” said the notables at last; “he shall himself decide what taxes will offer the least inconveniences, if the requirements of the state make it necessary to impose new sacrifices upon the people.”  “The notables have seen with dismay the depth of the evil caused by an administration whereof your parliament had more than once foreseen the consequence,” said the premier president of the parliament of Paris.  “The different plans proposed to your Majesty deserve careful deliberation.  The most respectful silence is at this moment our only course.”

The notables had themselves recognized their own impotence and given in their resignation.  A formal closing session took place on the 25th of May, 1787.  The keeper of the seals, enumerating the results of the labors of the Assembly, enregistered the royal promises as accomplished facts:  “All will be set right without any shock, without any ruin of fortunes, without any alteration in the principles of government, without any of those breaches of faith which should never be so much as mentioned in the presence of the monarch of France.

“The resolved or projected reform of various abuses, and the permanent good for which the way is being paved by new laws concerted with you, gentlemen, are about to co-operate successfully for the present relief of the people.

“Forced labor is proscribed, the gabel (or salt-tax) is revised (juyee), the obstacles which hamper home trade are destroyed, and agriculture, encouraged by the free exportation of grain, will become day by day more flourishing.

“The king has solemnly promised that disorder shall not appear again in his finances, and his Majesty is about to take the most effective measures for fulfilling this sacred engagement, of which you are the depositaries.

“The administration of the state will approach nearer and nearer to the government and vigilance of a private family, and a more equitable assessment, which personal interest will incessantly watch over, will lighten the burden of impositions.”

Only the provincial administrations were constituted; the hopes which had been conceived of the Assembly of notables remained more vague than before its convocation:  it had failed, like all the attempts at reform made in succession by Louis XVI.’s advisers, whether earnest or frivolous, whether proved patriots or ambitious intriguers.  It had, however, revealed to the whole country the deplorable disorder of the finances; it had taught the third estate and even the populace how deep was the repugnance among the privileged classes towards reforms which touched their interests.  Whilst spreading, as a letter written to America by M. de La Fayette put it, “the salutary habit of thinking about public affairs,” it had at the same time betrayed the impotence of the government, and the feebleness of its means of action.  It was a stride, and an immense stride, towards the Revolution.