some, eight thousand men; others say that the number
of dead on both sides did not amount to more than six
thousand.” The territorial results of
the victory were greater than the numerical losses
of the armies. Within a fortnight, the towns
of Caravaggio, Bergamo, Brescia, Crema, Cremona, and
Pizzighitone surrendered to the French. Peschiera
alone, a strong fortress at the southern extremity
of the Lake of Garda, resisted, and was carried by
assault. “It was a bad thing for those
within,” says the Loyal Serviteur of Bayard;
“for all, or nearly all, perished there; amongst
the which was the governor of the Signory and his
son, who were willing to pay good and heavy ransom;
but that served them not at all, for on one tree were
both of them hanged, which to me did seem great cruelty;
a very lusty gentleman, called the Lorrainer, had
their parole, and he had big words about it with the
grand master, lieutenant-general of the king; but
he got no good thereby.” The Memoires
of Robert de la Marck, lord of Fleuranges, and
a warrior of the day, confirm, as to this sad incident,
the story of the Loyal Serviteur of Bayard: “When
the French volunteers,” says he, “entered
by the breach into the castle of Peschiera, they cut
to pieces all those who were therein, and there were
left only the captain, the proveditore, and the podesta,
the which stowed themselves away in a tower, surrendered
to the good pleasure of the king, and, being brought
before him, offered him for ransom a hundred thousand
ducats; but the king swore, ’If ever I eat or
drink till they be hanged and strangled! ’Nor
even for all the prayer they could make could the
grand master Chaumont, and even his uncle, Cardinal
d’Amboise, find any help for it, but the king
would have them hanged that very hour.”
Some chroniclers attribute this violence on Louis
XII.’s part to a “low and coarse”
reply returned by those in command at Peschiera to
the summons to surrender. Guicciardini, whilst
also recording the fact, explains it otherwise than
by a fit of anger on Louis’s part: “The
king,” he says, “was led to such cruelty
in order that, dismayed at such punishment, those
who were still holding out in the fortress of Cremona
might not defend themselves to the last extremity.”
[Guicciardini, Istoria d’Italia, liv.
viii. t. i. p. 521.] So that the Italian historian
is less severe on this act of cruelty than the French
knight is.
Louis XII.’s victory at Agnadello had for him consequences very different from what he had no doubt expected. “The king,” says Guicciardini, “departed from Italy, carrying away with him to France great glory by reason of so complete and so rapidly won a victory over the Venetians; nevertheless, as in the case of things obtained after hope long deferred men scarcely ever feel such joy and happiness as they had at first imagined they would, the king took not back with him either greater peace of mind or greater security in respect of his affairs.” The