FOOTNOTES:
[1] Dr. Johnson’s Preface first appeared in
1765. Malone’s Shakespeare,
i. 108. and Boswell’s
Life of Johnson, i.
[2] Est vetus atque probus, centum qui perficit annos.
Hon. Ep. II. 1.
v. 39.
[3] With all respect for our great critic’s
memory we must maintain,
that love has the greatest
influence on the sum of life: and every
popular tale or poem derives
its main charm and power of pleasing
from the incidents of this
universal passion. Other passions have,
undoubtedly, their sway, but
love, when it does prevail, like
Aaron’s rod, swallows
up every feeling beside. It is one thing to
introduce the fulsome badinage
of compliment with which French
tragedy abounds, and another
to exhibit the
—“very ecstacy of love:
Whose violent property foredoes itself,
And leads the will to desperate undertakings,
As oft as any passion under heaven,
That does afflict our natures.”—
HAMLET. Act ii. Sc. i.
[4]
Quaerit quod nusquam est gentium,
repent tamen.
Facit illud verisimile, quod
mendacrium est.
PLAUTI
PSEUDOLUS, Act i. Sc. 4.
Ficta voluptatis causa, sint proxima veris. HOR. ARS POET, 338.
See too the celebrated passage
of Shakespeare himself—
Midsummer-night’s Dream, Act v. Sc.
1; and Idler, 84.—Ed.
[5] The judgment of French poets on these points may
be inferred from
the tenour of Boileau’s
admonitions:
Gardez donc de donner, ainsi que dans Clelie,
L’air ni l’esprit francois a l’antique Italie;
Et, sous des noms romains faisant notre portrait,
Peindre Caton galant, et Brutus dameret.
Art Poetique, iii.—Ed.
[6] The critic must, when he wrote this, have forgotten
the Cyclops of
Euripides, and also the fact,
that when an Athenian dramatist
brought out his three
tragedies at the Dionysiac festival, he
added, as a fourth, a sort
of farce; a specimen of which Schlegel
considers the Cyclops.
Mr. Twining, in his amusing and instructive
notes on Aristotle’s
Poetics, refers to the drunken jollity of
Hercules in the Alcestis,
and to the ludicrous dialogue between
Ulysses and Minerva, in the
first scene of the Ajax of Sophocles, as
instances of Greek tragi-comedy.
We may add the Electra of
Euripides; for if the poet
did not intend to burlesque the rules of
tragic composition in many
of the scenes of that play, and to make
his audience laugh, he calculated
on more dull gravity in Athens,
than we are accustomed to
give that city of song the credit for. The
broad ridicule which Aristophanes
casts against the tragedians is
not half so laughable.