he says, “are a poor and generally called barbarous
people, bred under the darkest ignorance; and yet
a bright and noble genius shines through these black
clouds. None of the greatest Roman heroes have
discovered a greater love of country, or contempt
of death, than these people, called barbarous, have
shown when liberty came in competition. Indeed
I think our Indians have outdone the Romans in this
particular. Some of the greatest of those Roman
heroes have murdered themselves to avoid shame or torments;
but our Indians have refused to die meanly or with
little pain, when they thought their country’s
honour would be at stake by it; but have given their
bodies willingly to the most cruel torments of their
enemies, to show, as they said, that ‘the Five
Nations’ consisted of men whose courage and
resolution could not be shaken. But what, alas!
have we Christians done to make them better?
We have, indeed, reason to be ashamed that these infidels,
by our conversation and neighbourhood, are become worse
than they were before they knew us. Instead of
virtue, we have only taught them vice, that they were
entirely free from before that time."[20] The Rev.
Timothy Flint, who was himself a missionary, in his
“Ten Years’ Residence in the Valley of
the Mississippi,” observes, page 144,—“I
have surely had it in my heart to impress them with
the importance of the subject (religion). I have
scarcely noticed an instance in which the subject was
not received either with indifference, rudeness, or
jesting. Of all races of men that I have seen,
they seem most incapable of religious impressions.
They have, indeed, some notions of an invisible agent,
but they seemed generally to think that the Indians
had their god as the whites had theirs.”
And again, “nothing will eventually be gained
to the great cause by colouring and mis-statement,”
alluding to the practice of the missionaries; “and
however reluctant we may be to receive it, the real
state of things will eventually be known to us.
We have heard of the imperishable labours of an Elliott
and a Brainard, in other days. But in these times
it is a melancholy truth, that Protestant exertions
to Christianize them have not been marked with apparent
success. The Catholics have caused many to hang
a crucifix around their necks, which they show as
they show their medals and other ornaments, and this
is too often all they have to mark them as Christians.
We have read the narratives of the Catholics, which
detailed the most glowing and animating views of success.
I have had accounts, however, from travellers in these
regions, that have been over the Stony mountains into
the great missionary settlements of St. Peter and
St. Paul. These travellers (and some of them
were professed Catholics) unite in affirming that the
converts will escape from the missions whenever it
is in their power, fly into their native deserts,
and resume at once their old mode of life.”