being the sign of the possessive; but if the words in themselves are possessives, then there must be two signs of the same case, which is absurd.”—­Improved Gram., p. 28; Phil.  Gr., 36.  I deny that of is here the sign of the possessive, and affirm that it is taken partitively, in all examples of this sort.  “I know my sheep, and am known of mine,” is not of this kind; because of here means by—­a sense in which the word is antiquated.  In recurring afterwards to this argument, the Doctor misquotes the following texts, and avers that they “are evidently meant to include the whole number:  ’Sing to the Lord, all ye saints of his.’—­Ps. 30, 4. ’He that heareth these sayings of mine.’—­Matt. 7.”—­Improved Gram., p. 29; Phil.  Gr., 38.  If he is right about the meaning, however, the passages are mistranslated, as well as misquoted:  they ought to be, “Sing unto the Lord, O ye his Saints.”—­“Every one that heareth these my sayings.”  But when a definitive particle precedes the noun, it is very common with us, to introduce the possessive elliptically after it; and what Dr. Wilson means by suggesting that it is erroneous, I know not:  “When the preposition of precedes mine, ours, yours, &c. the errour lies, not in this, that there are double possessive cases, but in forming an implication of a noun, which the substitute already denotes, together with the persons.”—­Essay on Gram., p. 110.

OBS. 14.—­In his Syllabus of English Grammar, Dr. Wilson teaches thus:  “My, our, thy, your, his, her, its, their, whose, and whosesoever are possessive pronominal adjectives.  Ours, yours, hers, and theirs are pronoun substantives, used either as subjects, or [as] objects; as singulars, or [as] plurals; and are substituted both for [the names of] the possessors, and [for those of the] things possessed. His, its, whose, mine, and thine, are sometimes used as such substantives; but also are at other times pronominal possessive adjectives.”—­Wilson’s Syllabus, p.  X. Now compare with these three positions, the following three from the same learned author.  “In Hebrew, the adjective generally agrees with its noun in gender and number, but pronouns follow the gender of their antecedents, and not of the nouns with which they stand.  So in English, my, thy, his, her, its, our, your, and their, agree with the nouns they represent, in number, gender, and person.  But adjectives, having no change expressive of number, gender, or case, cannot accord with their nouns.”—­Wilson’s Essay on Gram., p. 192. “Ours, yours, hers, and theirs, are most usually considered possessive cases of personal pronouns; but they are, more probably, possessive substitutes, not adjectives, but nouns.”—­Ib., p. 109.  “Nor can mine or thine, with any more propriety than ours, yours, &c. be joined to any noun, as possessive adjectives and possessive cases may.”—­Ib., p. 110.  Whoever understands these instructions, cannot but see their inconsistency.