rather confusedly says: “The parenthesis
() and hooks [] include a remark or clause, not essential
to the sentence in construction.”—Philosophical
Gram., p. 219; Improved Gram., p. 154.
But, in his Dictionary, he forgets both the hooks and
the parenthesis that are here spoken of; and, with
still worse confusion or inaccuracy, says: “The
parenthesis is usually included in hooks
or curved lines, thus, ().” Here he either
improperly calls these regular little curves “hooks,”
or erroneously suggests that both the hooks and the
curves are usual and appropriate signs of “the
parenthesis.” In Garner’s quarto
Dictionary, the French word Crochet, as used
by printers, is translated, “A brace, a crotchet,
a parenthesis;” and the English word Crotchet
is defined, “The mark of a parenthesis,
in printing, thus [ ].” But Webster defines
Crotchet, “In printing, a hook
including words, a sentence or a passage
distinguished from the rest, thus [].” This
again is both ambiguous and otherwise inaccurate.
It conveys no clear idea of what a crotchet is. One
hook includes nothing. Therefore Johnson
said: “Hooks in which words are included
[thus].” But if each of the hooks is a
crotchet, as Webster suggests, and almost every body
supposes, then both lexicographers are wrong in not
making the whole expression plural: thus, “Crotchets,
in printing, are angular hooks usually including
some explanatory words.” But is this all
that Webster meant? I cannot tell. He may
be understood as saying also, that a Crotchet
is “a sentence or a passage distinguished
from the rest, thus [];” and doubtless it would
be much better to call a hint thus marked, a crotchet,
than to call it a parenthesis, as some have
done. In Parker and Fox’s Grammar, and
also in Parker’s Aids to English Composition,
the term Brackets only is applied to these
angular hooks; and, contrary to all usage of other
authors, so far as I know, the name of Crotchets
is there given to the Curves. And then,
as if this application of the word were general, and
its propriety indisputable, the pupil is simply told:
“The curved lines between which a parenthesis
is enclosed are called Crotchets.”—Gram.,
Part III, p. 30; Aids, p. 40. “Called
Crotchets” by whom? That not even
Mr. Parker himself knows them by that name, the following
most inaccurate passage is a proof: “The
note of admiration and interrogation,
as also the parenthesis, the bracket,
and the reference marks, [are noted in the margin]
in the same manner as the apostrophe.”—Aids,
p. 314. In some late grammars, (for example,
Hazen’s and Day’s,) the parenthetic
curves are called “the Parentheses”
From this the student must understand that it always
takes two parentheses to make one parenthesis!
If then it is objectionable, to call the two marks
“a parenthesis,” it is much more
so, to call each of them by that name, or both “the
parentheses.” And since Murray’s
phrases are both entirely too long for common use,
what better name can be given them than this very
simple one, the Curves?