them.”—
Scougal, p. 99.
So, likewise, when an intransitive verb takes the
same case after as before it, by Rule 6th; as, “
Johnson
soon after engaged AS
usher in a school.”—
L.
Murray. “
He was employed AS
usher.”
In all these examples, the case that follows
as,
is determined by that which precedes. If after
the verb “
engaged” we supply
himself,
usher becomes objective, and is in apposition with
the pronoun, and not in agreement with
Johnson:
“He engaged
himself as
usher.”
One late writer, ignorant or regardless of the analogy
of General Grammar, imagines this case to be an “objective
governed by the conjunction
as,” according
to the following rule: “The conjunction
as, when it takes the meaning of
for,
or
in the character of, governs the objective
case; as, Addison,
as a
writer of prose,
is highly distinguished.”—
J.
M. Putnam’s Gram., p. 113. S. W. Clark,
in his grammar published in 1848, sets
as in
his list of
prepositions, with this example:
“’That England can spare from her service
such men
as HIM.’—
Lord Brougham.”—
Clark’s
Practical Gram., p. 92. And again: “When
the second term of a
Comparison of equality
is a Noun, or Pronoun, the
Preposition AS is
commonly used. Example—’He hath
died to redeem such a rebel
as ME.’—
Wesley.”
Undoubtedly, Wesley and Brougham here erroneously supposed
the
as to connect
words only, and consequently
to require them to be in the same case, agreeably
to OBS. 1st, above; but a moment’s reflection
on the sense, should convince any one, that the construction
requires the nominative forms
he and
I,
with the verbs
is and
am understood.
OBS. 8.—The conjunction as may also
be used between an adjective or a participle and the
noun to which the adjective or participle relates;
as, “It does not appear that brutes have the
least reflex sense of actions AS distinguished
from events; or that will and design, which constitute
the very nature of actions AS such,
are at all an object of their perception.”—Butler’s
Analogy, p. 277.
OBS. 9.—As frequently has the force
of a relative pronoun, and when it evidently
sustains the relation of a case, it ought to be called,
and generally is called, a pronoun, rather
than a conjunction; as, “Avoid such as are
vicious,”—Anon. “But
as many as received him,” &c.—John,
i, 12. “We have reduced the terms into as
small a number as was consistent with perspicuity
and distinction.”—Brightland’s
Gram., p. ix. Here as represents a
noun, and while it serves to connect the two parts
of the sentence, it is also the subject of a verb.
These being the true characteristics of a relative
pronoun, it is proper to refer the word to that class.