The Grammar of English Grammars eBook

Goold Brown
This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 4,149 pages of information about The Grammar of English Grammars.

The Grammar of English Grammars eBook

Goold Brown
This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 4,149 pages of information about The Grammar of English Grammars.
from Harris; what room is there for that common assertion, that, “Conjunctions connect the same moods and tenses of verbs,” which is a part of Murray’s eighteenth rule, and found in most of our grammars?  For no agreement is usually required between verbs that have separate nominatives; and if we supply a nominative wherever we do not find one for each verb, then in fact no two verbs will ever be connected by any conjunction.

OBS. 13.—­What agreement there must be, between verbs that are in the same construction, it is not easy to determine with certainty.  Some of the Latin grammarians tell us, that certain conjunctions connect “sometimes similar moods and tenses, and sometimes similar moods but different tenses.”  See Prat’s Grammatica Latina, Octavo, Part ii, p. 95.  Ruddiman, Adam, and Grant, omit the concord of tenses, and enumerate certain conjunctions which “couple like cases and moods.”  But all of them acknowledge some exceptions to their rules.  The instructions of Lindley Murray and others, on this point, may be summed up in the following canon:  “When verbs are connected by a conjunction, they must either agree in mood, tense, and form, or have separate nominatives expressed.”  This rule, (with a considerable exception to it, which other authors had not noticed.) was adopted by myself in the Institutes of English Grammar, and also retained in the Brief Abstract of that work, entitled, The First Lines of English Grammar.  It there stands as the thirteenth in the series of principal rules; but, as there is no occasion to refer to it in the exercise of parsing, I now think, a less prominent place may suit it as well or better.  The principle may be considered as being less certain and less important than most of the usual rules of syntax:  I shall therefore both modify the expression of it, and place it among the notes of the present code.  See Notes 5th and 6th below.

OBS. 14.—­By the agreement of verbs with each other in form, it is meant, that the simple form and the compound, the familiar form and the solemn, the affirmative form and the negative, or the active form and the passive, are not to be connected without a repetition of the nominative.  With respect to our language, this part of the rule is doubtless as important, and as true, as any other.  A thorough agreement, then, in mood, tense, and form, is generally required, when verbs are connected by and, or, or nor; and, under each part of this concord, there may be cited certain errors which ought to be avoided, as will by-and-by be shown.  But, at the same time, there seem to be many allowable violations of the rule, some or other of which may perhaps form exceptions to every part of it.  For example, the tense may be varied, as it often is in Latin; thus, “As the general state of religion has been, is, or shall be, affected by them.”—­Butlers Analogy, p. 241.  “Thou art righteous, O Lord, which art, and wast, and shall

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
The Grammar of English Grammars from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.