The plot contrived,
before the break of day
Saint Reynard through the hedge had made
his way;
The pale was next, but proudly with a
bound
He leapt the fence of the forbidden ground:
Yet fearing to be seen, within a bed
Of coleworts he conceal’d his wily
head;
Then skulk’d till afternoon, and
watch’d his time
(As murderers use) to perpetrate his crime.
Oh, hypocrite, ingenious to
destroy!
Oh, traitor, worse than Sinon was to Troy!
500
Oh, vile subverter of the Gallic reign,
More false than Gano was to Charlemagne!
Oh, Chanticleer, in an unhappy hour
Didst thou forsake the safety of thy bower!
Better for thee thou hadst believed thy
dream,
And not that day descended from the beam.
But here the doctors eagerly dispute:
Some hold predestination absolute;
Some clerks maintain, that Heaven at first
foresees,
And in the virtue of foresight decrees.
510
If this be so, then prescience binds the
will,
And mortals are not free to good or ill;
For what he first foresaw, he must ordain,
Or its eternal prescience may be vain:
As bad for us as prescience had not been:
For first, or last, he’s author
of the sin.
And who says that, let the blaspheming
man
Say worse even of the devil, if he can.
For how can that Eternal Power be just
To punish man, who sins because he must?
520
Or, how can he reward a virtuous deed,
Which is not done by us; but first decreed?
I cannot bolt this matter
to the bran,
As Bradwardin and holy Austin can;
If prescience can determine actions so
That we must do, because he did foreknow,
Or that, foreknowing, yet our choice is
free,
Not forced to sin by strict necessity;
This strict necessity they simple call,
Another sort there is conditional.
530
The first so binds the will, that things
foreknown
By spontaneity, not choice, are done.
Thus galley-slaves tug willing at their
oar,
Content to work, in prospect of the shore;
But would not work at all if not constrain’d
before.
That other does not liberty constrain,
But man may either act, or may refrain.
Heaven made us agents free to good or
ill,
And forced it not, though he foresaw the
will.
Freedom was first bestow’d on human
race, 540
And prescience only held the second place.
If he could make such agents
wholly free,
I not dispute, the point’s too high
for me;
For Heaven’s unfathom’d power
what man can sound,
Or put to his Omnipotence a bound?
He made us to his image, all agree;
That image is the soul, and that must
be,
Or not, the Maker’s image, or be
free.
But whether it were better man had been