“Think of it, Richard!  I, whom my mother considered interesting and of somewhat distinguished mien, owing to my pallor and slim stature!  A pudgy worm belongs to chestnuts, not to books.  A pudgy antiquarian is a thing unheard of since monastic days, when annal making was not deemed out of place if mingled with the rotund jollity of a Friar Tuck.  You must bear half the blame, for it must be the butter habit that your Martha Corkle’s fresh churned pats inoculated me with, for I always detested the stuff before.

“Graybeard’s stricture, however, struck a deeper chord—­’He has material in plenty for his book, but no vital stimulus.’  This, too, is deeply true, and I have felt it vaguely so for some time, but no more realized it than I did my pudginess.

“No matter how much material one collects, if the vitalizing spirit is not there, no matter how realistically the stage may be set if the actors are mere dummies.  The only use of the past is to illuminate and sustain the present.

“Your own home life and work, the honest questions of little Richard and Ian waken me from a long sleep, I believe, and set me thinking.  What is a man remembered by the longest?  Brain work, memorial building, or heart touching?  Do you recollect once meeting old Moore—­Clement Clark Moore—­at my father’s?  He was a profound scholar in Greek and Hebrew lexicology, and gave what was once his country house and garden in old Chelsea Village to the theological seminary of his professorship.  How many people remember this, or his scholarship?  But before that old rooftree was laid low, he wrote beneath it, quite offhand, a little poem, ‘The Night Before Christmas,’ that blends with childhood’s dreams anew each Christmas Eve—­a few short verses holding more vitality than all his learning.

“If my book ever takes body, my friend, it will be under your roof, where you and yours can vitalize it.  This is no fishing for invitations—­we know each other too frankly well for that.  What I wish to do is to come into your neighbourhood next springtime, without encroaching on your hospitality, and work some hours every day in the library, or that corner of her charmed attic that Barbara has shared with me.  It is bewitching.  Upon my word, I do not wonder that she sees the world rose-colour as she looks upon it from that window.  I, too, had long reveries there, in which experience and tradition mixed themselves so cleverly that for the time I could not tell whether it was my father or myself who had sometimes proudly escorted the lovely Carroll sisters upon their afternoon promenade down Broadway, from Prince Street to the Bowling Green, each leading her pet greyhound by a ribbon leash, or which of us it was that, in seeking to recapture an escaping hound, was upset by it in the mud, to the audible delight of some rivals in a ’bus and his own discomfiture, being rendered thereby unseemly for the beauty’s further company.”

* * * * *