It is
not unity; it is not, in the moral sense,
discipline. Nothing can be more united in a moral
sense than a French, British, or Russian regiment.
Nothing, for that matter, could be more united than
a Highland clan at Killiecrankie or a rush of religious
fanatics in the Soudan. What such engines, in
such size and multiplicity, really meant was this:
they meant a type of life naturally intolerable to
happier and more healthy-minded men, conducted on
a larger scale and consuming larger populations than
had ever been known before. They meant cities
growing larger than provinces, factories growing larger
than cities; they meant the empire of the slum.
They meant a degree of detailed repetition and dehumanised
division of labour, to which no man born would surrender
his brief span in the sunshine, if he could hope to
beat his ploughshare into a sword. The nations
of the earth were not to surrender to the Kaiser;
they were to surrender to Krupp, his master and theirs;
the French, the British, the Russians were to surrender
to Krupp as the Germans themselves, after a few swiftly
broken strikes, had already surrendered to Krupp.
Through every cogwheel in that incomparable machinery,
through every link in that iron and unending chain,
ran the mastery and the skill of a certain kind of
artist; an artist whose hands are never idle through
dreaming or drawn back in disgust or lifted in wonder
or in wrath; but sure and tireless in their touch
upon the thousand little things that make the invisible
machinery of life. That artist was there in triumph;
but he had no name. The ancient world called
him the Slave.
From this advancing machine of millions, the slighter
array of the Allies, and especially the British at
their ultimate outpost, saved themselves by a succession
of hair’s-breadth escapes and what must have
seemed to the soldiers the heartrending luck of a mouse
before a cat. Again and again Von Kluck’s
cavalry, supported by artillery and infantry, clawed
round the end of the British force, which eluded it
as by leaping back again and again. Sometimes
the pursuer was, so to speak, so much on top of his
prey that it could not even give way to him; but had
to hit such blows as it could in the hope of checking
him for the instant needed for escape. Sometimes
the oncoming wave was so close that a small individual
accident, the capture of one man, would mean the washing
out of a whole battalion. For day after day this
living death endured. And day after day a certain
dark truth began to be revealed, bit by bit, certainly
to the incredulous wonder of the Prussians, quite
possibly to the surprise of the French, and quite as
possibly to the surprise of themselves; that there
was something singular about the British soldiers.
That singular thing may be expressed in a variety of
ways; but it would be almost certainly expressed insufficiently
by anyone who had not had the moral courage to face
the facts about his country in the last decades before
the war. It may perhaps be best expressed by
saying that some thousands of Englishmen were dead:
and that England was not.