should be supposed to have grown up on his part against
his tormentor. This delicate task was managed
by the attorney with such consummate skill, that,
when the evidence on both sides was closed, public
sympathy, if not public conviction, had undergone a
very perceptible change. The prosecutors, aware
of this, felt the success of their case endangered,
and exerted themselves to the utmost to prevent the
tide, now almost in equilibrium, from ebbing back with
a violence proportionate to that of its flow.
But the argument even of their ablest champion, John
——, seemed almost puerile, in comparison
with this, the last effort of George ——,—an
effort which was long remembered, even less on account
of its melancholy termination than for its extraordinary
eloquence. The Kentuckians of that day were accustomed
to hear Breckenridge, Clay, Talbot, Allen, and Grundy,
all men of singular oratorical fame,—but
never, we have heard it affirmed, was a more moving
appeal poured into the ears of a Kentucky jury.
Availing himself of every resource of professional
skill, he now demonstrated, to the full satisfaction
of many, the utter inadequacy of the circumstantial
evidence upon which so much stress had been laid to
justify a conviction,—sifting and weighing
carefully every fact and detail, and trying the conclusions
that had been drawn therefrom by the most rigorous
and searching logic,—and then, assailing
the credibility of the testimony brought forward to
prove the habitual cruelty of his client, he gave
utterance to a withering torrent of invective and
sarcasm, in which the character of the main hostile
witness shrivelled and blackened like paper in a flame.
Then—having been eight hours on his feet—he
began to avail himself of that last dangerous resource
which genius only may use,—the final arrow
in the lawyer’s quiver, which is so hard to
handle rightly, and, failing, may prove worse than
useless, but, sped by a strong hand and true aim, often
tells decisively on a hesitating jury,—we
mean a direct appeal to their feelings. Like a
skilful leader who gathers all his exhausted squadrons
when he sees the crisis of battle approaching, the
great advocate seemed now to summon every overtaxed
power of body and spirit to his aid, as he felt that
the moment was come when he must wring an acquittal
from the hearts of his hearers. Nor did either
soul or intellect fail at the call. Higher and
stronger surged the tide of passionate eloquence, until
every one felt that the icy barrier was beginning
to yield,—for tears were already seen on
more than one of the faces now leaning breathlessly
forward from the jury-box to listen,—when
all at once a dead silence fell throughout the hall:
the voice whose organ-tones had been filling its remotest
nook suddenly died away in a strange gurgle. Several
physicians present immediately divined what had happened;
nor were the multitude near kept long in doubt; for
all saw, at the next moment, a crimson stream welling