accountable, guilty, deserving death for having done
his utmost to cheapen human life, when the proof of
its priceless worth lived in his own nature.
But to make him a slave, cheapens to nothing
universal human nature, and instead of healing
a wound, gives a death-stab. What! repair an
injury to rational being in the robbery of one of
its rights, not only by robbing it of all, but by annihilating
their foundation, the everlasting distinction
between persons and things? To make a man a chattel,
is not the punishment, but the annihilation
of a human being, and, so far as it goes, of
all human beings. This commutation of
the punishment of death, into perpetual slavery, what
a fortunate discovery! Alas! for the honor of
Deity, if commentators had not manned the forlorn hope,
and by a timely movement rescued the Divine character,
at the very crisis of its fate, from the perilous
position in which inspiration had carelessly left it!
Here a question arises of sufficient importance for
a separate dissertation; but must for the present
be disposed of in a few paragraphs. WERE THE
CANAANITES SENTENCED BY GOD TO INDIVIDUAL AND UNCONDITIONAL
EXTERMINATION? As the limits of this inquiry forbid
our giving all the grounds of dissent from commonly
received opinions, the suggestions made, will be thrown
out merely as QUERIES, rather than laid down as doctrines.
The directions as to the disposal of the Canaanites,
are mainly in the following passages, Ex. xxiii. 23-33;
xxxiv. 11; Deut. vii. 16-24; ix. 3; xxxi. 3-5.
In these verses, the Israelites are commanded to “destroy
the Canaanites,” to “drive out,”
“consume,” “utterly overthrow,”
“put out,” “dispossess them,”
&c. Did these commands enjoin the unconditional
and universal destruction of the individuals,
or merely of the body politic? The word
haram, to destroy, signifies national,
as well as individual destruction; the destruction
of political existence, equally with personal;
of governmental organization, equally with the lives
of the subjects. Besides, if we interpret the
words destroy, consume, overthrow, &c., to mean personal
destruction, what meaning shall we give to the expressions,
“drive out before thee,” “cast out
before thee,” “expel,” “put
out,” “dispossess,” &c., which are
used in the same and in parallel passages? In
addition to those quoted above, see Josh. iii. 10;
xvii. 18; xxiii. 5; xxiv. 18; Judg. i. 20, 29-35;
vi. 9. “I will destroy all the people
to whom thou shalt come, and I will make all thine
enemies turn their backs unto thee.”
Ex. xxiii. 27. Here “all their enemies”
were to turn their backs, and “all
the people” to be “destroyed.”
Does this mean that God would let all their enemies
escape, but kill their friends, or that he
would first kill “all the people”
and THEN make them “turn their backs,”
an army of runaway corpses? In Josh. xxiv. 8,