One great cause of this deterioration is the insatiable
thirst for novelty, which, becoming weary even of
excellence, will “sate itself in a celestial
bed, and prey on garbage.” In the torpidity
produced by an utter exhaustion of sensual enjoyment,
the Arreoi Club of Otaheite is recorded to have found
a miserable excitement, by swallowing the most revolting
filth; and the jaded intellectual appetites of more
civilized communities will sometimes seek a new stimulus
in changes almost as startling. Some adventurous
writer, unable to obtain distinction among a host of
competitors, all better qualified than himself to win
legitimate applause, strikes out a fantastic or monstrous
innovation; and arrests the attention of many who
would fall asleep over monotonous excellence.
Imitators are soon found;—fashion adopts
the new folly;—the old standard of perfection
is deemed stale and obsolete;—and thus,
by degrees, the whole literature of a country becomes
changed and deteriorated. It appears to us, that
we are now labouring in a crisis of this nature.
In our last Number, we noticed the revolution in our
poetry; the transition from the lucid terseness and
exquisite polish of Pope and Goldsmith, to the rambling,
diffuse, irregular, and imaginative style of composition
by which the present era is characterized; and we
might have added, that a change equally complete, though
diametrically opposite in its tendency, has been silently
introduced into our prose. In this we have oscillated
from freedom to restraint;—from the easy,
natural, and colloquial style of Swift, Addison and
Steele, to the perpetually strained, ambitious, and
overwrought stiffness, of which the author we are
now considering affords a striking exemplification.
“He’s knight o’ the shire, and represents
them all.” There is not the smallest keeping
in his composition:—less solicitous what
he shall say, than how he shall say it, he exhausts
himself in a continual struggle to produce effect
by dazzling, terrifying, or surprising. Annibal
Caracci was accused of an affectation of muscularity,
and an undue parade of anatomical knowledge, even
upon quiescent figures: But the artist whom we
are now considering has no quiescent figures:—even
his repose is a state of rigid tension, if not extravagant
distortion. He is the Fuseli of novelists.
Does he deem it necessary to be energetic, he forthwith
begins foaming at the mouth, and falling into convulsions;
and this orgasm is so often repeated, and upon such
inadequate occasions, that we are perpetually reminded
of the tremendous puerilities of the Della Cruscan
versifiers, or the ludicrous grand eloquence of the
Spaniard, who tore a certain portion of his attire,
“as if heaven and earth were coming together.”
In straining to reach the sublime, he perpetually
takes that single unfortunate step which conducts him
to the ridiculous —a failure which, in
a less gifted author, might afford a wicked amusement
to the critic, but which, when united with such undoubted
genius as the present work exhibits, must excite a
sincere and painful regret in every admirer of talent.