reply, but also communicating personally upon the
subject with Buonarroti. Three of Michelangelo’s
letters on the subject to the Duke have been preserved.
After giving a short history of the project, and alluding
to the fact that Leo X. began the church, he says
that the Florentines had appointed a building committee
of five men, at whose request he made several designs.
One of these they selected, and according to his own
opinion it was the best. “This I will have
copied and drawn out more clearly than I have been
able to do it, on account of old age, and will send
it to your Most Illustrious Lordship.”
The drawings were executed and carried to Florence
by the hand of Tiberio Calcagni. Vasari, who has
given a long account of this design, says that Calcagni
not only drew the plans, but that he also completed
a clay model of the whole church within the space
of two days, from which the Florentines caused a larger
wooden model to be constructed. Michelangelo
must have been satisfied with his conception, for
he told the building-committee that “if they
carried it out, neither the Romans nor the Greeks ever
erected so fine an edifice in any of their temples.
Words the like of which neither before nor afterwards
issued from his lips; for he was exceedingly modest.”
Vasari, who had good opportunities for studying the
model, pronounced it to be “superior in beauty,
richness and variety of invention to any temple which
was ever seen.” The building was begun,
and 5000 crowns were spent upon it. Then money
or will failed. The model and drawings perished.
Nothing remains for certain to show what Michelangelo’s
intentions were. The present church of S. Giovanni
dei Fiorentini in Strada Giulia is the work of Giacomo
della Porta, with a facade by Alessandro Galilei.
Of Tiberio Calcagni, the young Florentine sculptor
and architect, who acted like a kind of secretary
or clerk to Michelangelo, something may here be said.
The correspondence of this artist with Lionardo Buonarroti
shows him to have been what Vasari calls him, “of
gentle manners and discreet behaviour.”
He felt both veneration and attachment for the aged
master, and was one of the small group of intimate
friends who cheered his last years. We have seen
that Michelangelo consigned the shattered Pieta to
his care; and Vasari tells us that he also wished
him to complete the bust of Brutus, which had been
begun, at Donato Giannotti’s request, for the
Cardinal Ridolfi. This bust is said to have been
modelled from an ancient cornelian in the possession
of a certain Giuliano Ceserino. Michelangelo
not only blocked the marble out, but brought it nearly
to completion, working the surface with very fine-toothed
chisels. The sweetness of Tiberio Calcagni’s
nature is proved by the fact that he would not set
his own hand to this masterpiece of sculpture.
As in the case of the Pieta, he left Buonarroti’s
work untouched, where mere repairs were not required.
Accordingly we still can trace the fine-toothed marks